Episcopal priest Ben Day wins battle, loses war

Perjuring priest Ben Day

Cobb County, GA, judicial records indicate that Art Blackburn, a former parishioner at Christ Church, Kennesaw, GA, pled guilty to a misdemeanor and was sentenced to a year’s probation. And while some may argue that Episcopal priest Ben Day got what he wanted — which … Read more

Why doesn’t the Episcopal Church heal itself?

The Episcopal Church is Dying

As we watch the Episcopal Church plunging toward oblivion, we ask the question, “Why doesn’t the church do something?” The answer, we believe, can be found at the parish level. Specifically, very few Episcopal parishes are spiritually healthy. And those that are unhealthy rarely recognize … Read more

More on St. Paul’s Montvale, one year later

Bishop Carlye Hughes

It’s been roughly a year since things unraveled at St. Paul’s, Montvale, NJ, thanks to the abusive behavior of a group of dissidents led by Jeff Piatt and Beth Abrahamson.  This post examines where the situation is now and explores bishop Carlye Hughes’ dismal handling of … Read more

Sad news from St. Paul’s Montvale

St Paul’s Montvale closes its doors

Curiosity may have killed the cat, but mendacity marred the ministry of St. Paul’s Montvale. And yes, we are thinking of the group we generously term “the dissidents” and their abusive behavior. In a letter sent moments ago to parishioners, dissidents, and others, Bishop Carlye … Read more

A shout-out to the Montvale dissidents

Beth Abrahamson

In recent weeks, the Montvale dissidents have been relatively quiet as they await their trial date for criminal trespass. Instead, reliable sources tell us that the group has actively been trying to make Pastor Jill Williams’ life miserable with a torrent of Title IV complaints. … Read more

More on St. Paul’s Montvale

An alleged reimbursement check, just shy of the amount requiring IRS reporting

Pastor Jill Williams has left St. Paul’s Montvale. That’s a pity, because she is probably the best priest we’ve met. And given our dubious view of Planet Episcopal, we don’t say that lightly.

Useless bishop: Carlye Hughes

Carlyle Hughes

Today we cover Carlye Hughes, the 11th bishop of the Diocese of Newark. We conclude that she is mainly useless. To be sure, we had high hopes when she came into office. Her questions and answers seemed to hit the nail on the head, talking … Read more

More on Montvale: Dissidents continue to lose

Rusty Miller Montvale

The St. Paul’s Montvale dissidents have again made a mess of things, even as they continue to display a remarkable lack of insight. That’s the word of court officials and others close to the matter, following an abortive effort at court-ordered mediation. ”The dissidents just … Read more

St. Paul’s Montvale update

Rusty Miller Montvale

It’s been a while since we posted about St. Paul’s Montvale, as we wanted to avoid tramping on any judicial toes while litigation is under way. With that in mind, we have a couple of updates. Heterophobia lawsuit First, Rusty Miller’s “heterophobia” lawsuit, aka “The … Read more

Unwilling to condemn torture, St. Paul’s Alexandria goes for tortured logic and feel-good theology

St. Paul’s Alexandria

Anglican Watch first reported, nearly four months ago, prominent members and leaders of St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Alexandria, Va., Anne and David Ayers, appear to be owners in the company behind the post-9/11 torture program. Under that initiative, mostly Muslim men, many of whom were never charged with a crime, were waterboarded, given forced anal feedings, and subjected to mock executions among   other horrific tactics. TheEpiscopal … Read more

Update: St. Paul’s Montvale dissidents go to trial

St. Paul’s dissidents are childish and hateful

Anglican Watch has learned that the St. Paul’s Montvale dissidents go on trial September 28 on criminal charges of defiant trespass. The matter will be heard late afternoon. The defendants include: Marc Denbeaux Maria and Leigh Hopper Anne Bosch Jane Moser Joe and Vicki Solis Rusty, … Read more

Breaking: Montvale dissidents lied to Mayor Ghassali in St. Paul’s conflict

Montvale Dissidents Busted for Lying

Anglican Watch recently obtained email records between Montvale mayor Mike Ghassali and various people, including the St. Paul’s dissidents. As we expected, they document several things: Steve Hopper lied about the meeting between Mayor Ghassali and Pastor Jill. After seeing Hopper’s dishonest e-mail, Mayor Ghassali busted … Read more

Montvale dissident Gene Muller seeks to stop financial investigations

Gene Miller, Montvale dissident

Anglican Watch has learned from well-placed sources that a member of the dissident faction has put out feelers to members of St. Paul’s parish in Montvale, N.J., seeking an end to the ongoing investigation into past financial activity at the parish. Gene Muller, a previous member … Read more

Further reflections on Russell Miller’s “hetero-phobia” lawsuit

Russell Miller, former Westwood School Board Member and hater

Following our post yesterday about Russell Miller’s spurious lawsuit against St. Paul’s Montvale, the Episcopal Diocese of Newark, and various related individuals, Anglican Watch further investigated Miller’s claims. Following is additional context for Miller’s lawsuit. We also reflect on Miller’s claims and his conduct. Specifically, we believe … Read more

Breaking news: St. Pauls Montvale update

Debbie Piatt

Sources close to the matter tell Anglican Watch that the court hearing on criminal charges involving Jeff Piatt and other former St. Paul’s Montvale members has been continued until September 28. The charges filed allegedly include defiant trespass. Anglican Watch believes that the news may indicate that the … Read more

Don’t holler. Boycott Wahler!

Don’t Holler. Boycott Wahler!

For those of you who don’t like Montvale contractor Joseph Wahler’s sexist, homophobic and violent remarks, here’s your chance to deploy a little of that cancel culture he decries in his posts about St. Paul’s Episcopal priest Jill Williams. Wahler’s on Facebook here, and we … Read more

Montvale update: Mennonites say “no mas” to the dissidents

Debbie Piatt

Last night, representatives of the Lombard Mennonite Peace Center (LMPC) met with the St. Paul’s Montvale dissidents. Sources close to the matter tell Anglican Watch that LMPC has recommended against further efforts at reconciliation with the dissidents due to their behavior and objectives, both of which are … Read more

More on Montvale: The curious case of Mark Denbeaux

Marc Denbeaux at the March on Selma

One of the interesting characters among the St. Paul’s dissidents is Mark Denbeaux. What makes him intriguing is the juxtaposition between his legal career, which includes his work on civil rights, his efforts on behalf of Guantanamo Bay detainees, and his exploration of First Amendment … Read more

Update: St. Paul’s Montvale

Debbie Piatt

Ed.: We earlier posted an update about further bad behavior on the part of Jeff and Debbie Piatt. We have pulled the post, as we believe we will have additional updates early next week. In the meantime, we remind readers of the Piatt’s continued defamation of … Read more

Breaking news: Jeff Piatt threatens Episcopal clergy

Threatening Letter from Jeff Piatt

DARVO. It’s an acronym heard often in analyses of abusive relationships. It stands for “Deny and Reverse Victim and Offender.” And it indicates that the person pulling a DARVO is likely abusive. And so it is with Jeff Piatt, who has retained legal counsel and … Read more

Update: St. Paul’s protestors retain legal counsel

Breaking News

Early information received by Anglican Watch indicates that the St. Paul’s Montvale protestors have retained legal counsel. The move is in response to criminal charges for defiant trespassing, filed by Montvale police against 11 individuals, including local attorney Marc Denbeaux. Others charged include: Jeff Piatt Maria and … Read more

St. Paul’s update: Jeff Piatt continues gaslighting

Montvale Landscaping/Jeff Piatt

Earlier today, Jeff Piatt, owner of Montvale Landscaping, sent an email that continues his efforts at gaslighting. Sent to the clergy of the Diocese of Newark, the email is included above. It is the contention of Anglican Watch that Piatt’s email underscores that he has no remorse … Read more

Anglican Watch believes prison sentence appropriate for Jeff Piatt

Anglican Watch Believes Jeff Piatt Deserves Jail Time

Sources close to the matter tell Anglican Watch that hearings will be held this Wednesday for several persons charged with defiant trespass after refusing to comply with the directive from the St. Paul’s vestry not to enter the property. Those charged allegedly include: Jeff Piatt Maria and … Read more

Still more allegations emerge about Jeff Piatt and Montvale Landscaping

Montvale Landscaping

Earlier today, Anglican Watch learned that a Sarbane-Oxley whistleblower complaint has been made to banking officials about questionable financial activity on the part of Jeff Piatt, Beth Abrahamson, Montvale Landscaping, and others connected with the group. Under Sarbanes-Oxley, publicly traded companies must take action in the event … Read more