The Top Ten Toxic Terrors of TEC for 2026

It’s time for Anglican Watch to announce the Top Ten Toxic Terrors of The Episcopal Church (TEC). As always, it was a fierce fight among the finalists, but several managed to claw and scratch their way to the very top of the cesspool. There’s no cash prize. Having reviewed this year’s expense reports, we thought it best to lock up the credit card.

The rankings are ours. The finalists have supplied much of the material themselves in parish letters, court filings and, in one memorable case, a broadcast of Morning Prayer.

And now, coming in at number 10 in a hard-fought race…

10. The Rt. Rev. Glenda Curry, retired bishop of Alabama

Bishop Glenda Curry
Bishop Glenda Curry

The former bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Alabama retired this year. Among the items she left her successor was the case of the Rev. Richard Losch. The diocese says it fully restricted his ministry in 2023. Jack testified that Losch raped him when he was twelve. Losch denied it, and the jury deadlocked in 2025. We believe Jack. While Curry was in office, we held police records and interview notes bearing on his case. Nobody from the diocesan investigation asked us for them. Curry got a retirement date. Jack is still waiting for the church to tell him how this ends.

Episcopal priest Richard Losch
Richard Losch, the priest whose case is discussed above.

9. The Rev. Matthew Machowski, rector of St. Stephen’s Episcopal Church in Coconut Grove, Florida

Anglican WatchA leather harness is an interesting fashion choice for a priest. Talk about top-ten things we didn’t need to see.

A third-party Title IV complaint alleged that Machowski had repeated affairs during his previous marriage and maintained that he had never agreed to monogamy. We interviewed his former husband and reviewed the disciplinary filings. The Diocese of Southeast Florida hired a former federal prosecutor to investigate. Its reference panel closed the case with what it called a “robust” pastoral response, including oversight of Machowski’s ministry — even as it largely ignored the facially obvious adultery.

When we reported on the decision, we could find no sign that anyone from the diocese had asked his former husband what help he needed. How robust does a pastoral response have to get before somebody picks up the phone? And to be clear: Marriage equality should mean just that: Equality. If heterosexual clergy are routinely defrocked for adultery, LGBTQ+ clergy should be held to the same standard.

8. Robert “Bobby” Smith, former chief executive officer of Saint Francis Ministries

Robert “Bobby” Smith
Robert “Bobby” Smith

Father Bobby ran Saint Francis Ministries, a Kansas foster care agency. In February, he pleaded guilty to one federal count of wire fraud involving a $6,909.73 credit card payment. In court, he acknowledged putting personal expenses on the charity’s card and approving fraudulent invoices. The agency served about 3,100 children when he resigned. His expenses included meals at five-star restaurants. Five words for the next board retreat ought to do it. Buy your own damn dinner.

7. Jeff Taylor, former director of youth ministries at The Falls Church

Jeff Taylor
Jeff Taylor

Taylor ran youth ministry at The Falls Church when it was an Episcopal parish. A church-commissioned investigation found in 2024 that his conduct with boys included sexual grooming and abuse. This September, federal prosecutors brought enticement and travel charges. Taylor pleaded not guilty.

In 2007, a former member of Cornerstone, the church’s youth group, reported that Taylor had abused him. The rector, the Rev. John Yates, listed seven young men from the same group and asked those he could reach whether they had experienced similar abuse. A staff member and a parent then compiled a broader contact list so the parish could ask other former participants the same question. The investigator found no formal parish effort to contact the people on that list. We suspect the list would have fared better in the stewardship office.

6. Scott Andrews, senior warden of Trinity Upperville

Scott Andrews, senior warden of Trinity Episcopal Church in Upperville
Scott Andrews

Vestry members at Trinity Episcopal Church in Upperville told us that Andrews hired law firm Simms Showers after complaints about the rector. The firm advertises church sex abuse investigations in which it delivers a confidential report to leadership. Several vestry members told us investigators pressed them to identify the source of a leak. We have a question the senior warden ought to be able to answer without billing anyone in six-minute increments. Do the families who raised concerns get to read the report, or just the people who hired the lawyers?

5. Ed Monk, former rector of St. John’s Episcopal Church in Corsicana

Ed Monk
Ed Monk

Monk’s lawyer had an explanation for the financial mess at St. John’s Episcopal Church in Corsicana, Texas. “Sloppy bookkeeping, sloppy governance,” he told the Episcopal Court of Review. Prosecutors charged the rector with felonies including theft of more than $300,000. A diocesan investigator reported that someone had opened a credit card account using the elderly treasurer’s Social Security number. We’d be interested to see which bookkeeping error fills out a credit card application.

On one point, Monk’s lawyer had a good case. In March, the court ordered a new church hearing because the Diocese of Dallas had mishandled the first one. Among the problems the court cited was the exclusion of Monk’s counsel from part of the proceedings. That ruling settled a question about the hearing. The allegations about the money still deserve an answer on the evidence.

As for the claim by Monk’s attorney that an ecclesiastical trial somehow tramples his client’s constitutional rights, spare us. Oh, and that bit about sloppy governance is an admission that Monk violated Canon IV.4.1(e), which requires clergy to “safeguard the property and funds of the Church and Community.”

Oops.

4. The Rev. Barb Kempf, Title IV intake officer for bishops

Barb Kempf
Barb Kempf

The church’s intake officer for bishops has given us a puzzle worthy of an adult forum. Canon IV.8.1 says the bishop must arrange an appropriate pastoral response when a report reaches intake. In a written response we published, Kempf concluded that a bishop’s alleged failure to provide one did not constitute a disciplinary offense in that case. Why? Because he’d never done the very thing the canons require him to do. Gotta wonder how Barb made it through law school.

Meanwhile, she still struggles to grasp that neither she nor the reference panel has any fact-finding authority.

It’s really not that difficult, Barb.

3. The Rev. Jonathan Adams, former rector of Trinity Upperville

Jonathan Adams
Jonathan Adams

In his July 12 letter to Trinity Upperville, Adams told parishioners the investigations established that he had done nothing inappropriate or harmful to young people. Now read the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia’s account. The sheriff found no violation of law. The church found conduct inappropriate for a priest and sent Adams back under a disciplinary agreement with specific directions. He resigned effective October 12.

It takes a certain gift to come home with a disciplinary agreement and write yourself a character reference. His “Johnny Boy” handle and his questionable veracity gave him the extra oomph he needed to claw his way into the top three.

2. The Rev. Mark Schultz, associate for pastoral care at Saint Thomas Church Fifth Avenue

Mark Schultz
Mark Schultz

An adult parishioner who had met with Schultz for pastoral care alleged in a civil complaint that Schultz sexually assaulted him at a gathering in the priest’s home. Schultz denied the allegation. The plaintiff withdrew the suit with prejudice. The rector and wardens of Saint Thomas Church Fifth Avenue said the parish-commissioned investigation found no evidence to substantiate the allegations. We believe the parishioner and have reported that the investigators did not interview him. A curious person might have started there.

Anyone wondering whether Schultz returned to the altar can consult the parish calendar for March 27. There he is, listed as celebrant for the Way of the Cross. The parish also lists him as associate for pastoral care. On the parishioner’s account, Schultz has an odd notion of Christian hospitality. Where but the Diocese of New York does a parishioner report that his priest sexually assaulted him and get a dismissal letter calling the priest’s conduct “appropriate”? And like Barb Kempf, the Episcopal Diocese of New York doesn’t give a red rat’s rear end what the canons say. Its intake officer and reference panel apparently think they can make findings of fact anyway.

1. Dan McClain, deposed Episcopal priest and former priest-in-charge of St. Paul’s in Dayton

Dan McClain
Dan McClain

Our No. 2 finisher in 2023 finally takes the top spot. The Court of Review upheld the finding based on McClain’s admitted affair while he was still married. Among the details in the court’s opinion was his decision to broadcast Morning Prayer from the deck of his partner’s home. Many a rector has struggled to get parishioners to pay attention to the Daily Office. We imagine the location shoot helped.

The court threw out broader findings based on disputed facts that the diocesan panel never tested at a hearing. The admitted conduct was enough. Bishop Kristin Uffelman White formally deposed McClain from the priesthood. We filed the complaint, so readers know where we stood. Dan moves up one place on our list and loses the collar. Quite a year.

Runners-up in a photo finish — the Very Rev. Winnie Varghese and the Rev. Canon Mark Anderson

Dean Winnie Varghese
Winnie Varghese, dean of the Cathedral Church of St. John the Divine in New York

Varghese missed the top ten by a whisker. She inherited the deficit at New York’s Cathedral Church of St. John the Divine. She also chairs the Community Good Episcopal Federal Credit Union, for which the Cathedral’s proposed 2027 budget included $372,000. Meanwhile, the Cathedral’s plans contemplated eliminating two full-time maintenance jobs and put $70,000 toward renovating the dean’s kitchen. We’d like to hear Varghese explain those priorities to the maintenance crew. On paper, at least, the kitchen has better job security.

If Varghese has accomplished one thing, she’s made our phone ring off the hook. Callers have complained about how she treats Cathedral employees and how she treated staff when she was rector of St. Luke’s Episcopal Church in Atlanta.

Jewel-encrusted “Queen of Mean” tiara with arched silver eyebrows and emerald eyes casting a sideways glance.
The Queen of Mean tiara. When the jeweler asked which stones Her Majesty preferred, she said, “Yes.”
Mark Anderson in a cropped screen capture
Canon Mark Anderson, vicar of St. John’s Cathedral in Jacksonville. Cropped from a screen capture in earlier Anglican Watch coverage.

Running neck and neck with Varghese is Anderson, vicar of St. John’s Cathedral in Jacksonville. He helped pitch a pledge campaign asking a household giving 3% of its income to make it 4%. For a local household earning the median income, that’s about $800 more a year. Anderson budgets nearly that much a month for vacations. In his divorce case, he sought alimony to maintain his standard of living and testified that his vacation budget includes trips to see his girlfriend. “Is it all about you?” Anderson asked from the pulpit. Your turn to answer, Canon.

Satirical coronation throne reserved for Canon Anderson, with crown, orb, scepter and a card reading “Kindly send the bill to Wife & Daddy.”
Canon Anderson graciously accepts the crown. The invoice may be presented to the rest of the family.

Sources

3 thoughts on “The Top Ten Toxic Terrors of TEC for 2026”

Leave a comment