The Episcopal Diocese of Alabama has unfinished business: Richard Losch, a priest accused of raping a boy at a New Hampshire Scout camp in 1976. His April 2025 criminal trial ended in a hung jury; he denies the allegations. The diocese says it restricted his ministry in 2023, but we have found no public order removing him from the priesthood. Its new bishop, Richard T. Lawson III, must pursue that removal through the church’s disciplinary process.
Anglican Watch called for action before Lawson’s June 27 consecration. A new bishop’s name on the letterhead is not the accountability we requested.
A hung jury is no excuse
“Jack,” a pseudonym, testified that Losch raped him during the camping trip. Jack says his brother testified that, while they were in high school, Jack told him Losch had molested him when he was younger. According to Jack, his brother also reported that disclosure during both police investigations. The jury’s deadlock produced neither a conviction nor an acquittal.
The Episcopal Church’s Title IV disciplinary system uses a different standard: Canon IV.19.16 requires clear and convincing evidence, below criminal proof beyond a reasonable doubt. We believe the evidence more than warrants Losch’s removal. The priesthood is not a consolation prize for avoiding conviction.
Grooming is part of the alleged abuse
In a direct communication with Anglican Watch, Jack detailed conduct he describes as grooming. He alleges that Losch:
- Showered with preteen boys.
- Watched boys change clothes.
- Spoke enthusiastically about skinny-dipping.
- Watched boys skinny-dip and participated in skinny-dipping with them.
- Took numerous overnight wilderness trips alone with boys.
- Warned boys that they might have to share his sleeping bag—remarks Jack says his brother reported to police investigators.
- Talked about having taken photographs of naked boys.
Jack says he found Facebook posts by Losch and newspaper articles documenting overnight trips with boys. He also says his brother’s report of Losch’s remarks about sharing sleeping bags should be reflected in the official investigative record.
In pretrial rulings, the court excluded evidence of alleged grooming as “prior bad acts.” Jack says the conduct listed above was among the material the jury was not permitted to hear. We believe the court erred.
Grooming is how abuse is prepared: trust cultivated, boundaries eroded, access arranged. Treating the alleged preparation as disconnected misconduct removes essential context from the alleged rape. The church has no excuse for ignoring it.
This also underscores the need to expressly criminalize sexual grooming, with clear definitions covering deliberate preparation of a child for sexual exploitation, in person and online. Lawmakers should close gaps with enforceable provisions requiring proof of sexual intent and specified conduct. That reform concerns future cases; the church can act now.
Jack also alleges Losch lied to investigators
Jack further alleges that Losch lied to investigators in Alabama when questioned after his indictment. According to Jack, an Alabama investigator testified at trial that Losch had described a fall trip involving a female teacher and both boys and girls.
Jack says he and two other boys testified that the trip occurred in the spring, with Losch and only boys. That conflict over the season and who was present demands examination in the church’s disciplinary process.
Restriction is not removal
Other churches distinguish criminal verdicts from clergy discipline. The Roman Catholic Church’s U.S. rules require permanent ministry removal when child sexual abuse is admitted or established through church proceedings, with dismissal from the clerical state when warranted. A criminal conviction is not required.
The Archdiocese of Chicago removed a pastor from his parish while investigating grooming and sexual-misconduct allegations involving seminarians. The United Methodist Church has revoked recognition of ministerial credentials through its own misconduct proceedings.
Alabama says it fully restricted Losch’s ministry in August 2023. More than three years later, we are still demanding a final disciplinary outcome: deposition. Parking a priest indefinitely is not the same as holding him accountable.
Jack should not have to beg
So far, we have seen zero sign of care or compassion from the diocese for Jack, the victim of Losch’s alleged rape. A survivor should not need a guilty verdict to persuade a church to behave like a church.
Canon IV.8.1 requires a pastoral response when a report reaches intake and a professional pastoral-care assessment for sexual-misconduct allegations. Canon IV.8.2 expressly includes consideration of care for the complainant and family. These are duties, not optional extras in the diocesan brochure.
We believe Jack. We stand with him 100 percent. He deserves care, dignity, and a church willing to impose consequences.
Close the checkbook
Until there is accountability for Losch, morally bankrupt is the only description we can offer for the Diocese of Alabama. Allowing him to remain a priest is a travesty. Faithfulness does not require financing it.
We call on everyone who believes child rape is wrong to withhold time, talent, and treasure from the Diocese of Alabama and its churches until Losch is removed from the clerical state. Tell Lawson why. The collection plate can wait; Jack has waited long enough.
Update — November 16, 2026: We clarified and expanded this article based on additional information provided directly by “Jack.” The revisions specify his account that, while in high school, he disclosed earlier molestation to his brother, who later testified about that disclosure and reported it during both police investigations. They also clarify his account of his brother’s reports to investigators about sleeping-bag remarks and the conflicting trial testimony about the camping trip’s season and participants. We added Jack’s statement that he found Facebook posts by Losch and newspaper articles documenting overnight trips with boys. We also removed a comparison to Texas’s child-grooming law and its source link because the case has no Texas connection.
Sources
- Direct communications from “Jack” to Anglican Watch — His grooming allegations; his account of his brother’s testimony and reports during both police investigations; his identification of Facebook posts and newspaper articles documenting overnight trips; and his account of conflicting trial testimony about the trip’s season and participants. Jack says his brother reported Losch’s sleeping-bag remarks to police investigators.
- Lawson’s consecration — Confirms his June 27, 2026, succession. Our earlier open letter — Documents the demand for action before he took office.
- Marblehead Current trial coverage — Reports testimony, Losch’s denial, and the hung jury.
- Anglican Watch’s mistrial report — Our reporting on the exclusion of grooming evidence.
- Episcopal Constitution and Canons — Governs disciplinary proof, pastoral duties, and deposition.
- U.S. Department of Justice guidance — Explains grooming’s role in abuse.
- Catholic safeguarding rules — Specifies permanent ministry removal following admitted or established abuse. Chicago’s official letter — Announces removal from a parish during a grooming investigation.
- United Methodist Judicial Council decision 1332 — Upholds disciplinary removal and revocation of recognized credentials.
- AL.com reporting republished by Speakin’ Out News — Quotes Alabama’s August 2023 ministry restriction.




