Source alleges dozens of instances of adultery by openly gay Episcopal priest Matthew Machowski, rector of St. Stephen’s Episcopal, Coconut Grove, Florida

Disclosure: Machowski was ordained while serving at Grace Episcopal Alexandria, a parish previously attended by Anglican Watch editor Eric Bonetti and his husband.

Bonetti has not been involved in production of this post.

A source within the Episcopal Diocese of Southeast Florida tells Anglican Watch that openly gay Episcopal priest Matthew Machowski, rector of St. Stephen’s Episcopal in Coconut Grove, committed multiple acts of adultery while married to another man. Machowski allegedly did so despite being married in the Episcopal Church and expressly vowing to “forsake all others.” Moreover, we conclude Machowski engaged in adulterous activity following his ordination as an Episcopal priest.

Machowski did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Our source is able to identify numerous alleged incidents of adultery on Machowski’s part, including names, dates, and specific details. While we have been unable to confirm this information, many of those with whom Machowski allegedly committed adultery were also married.

Based on the information we have received, Anglican Watch believes that Machowski has committed adultery on dozens of occasions, extending back to Machowski’s time in the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia.

Our source appears likely to file a Title IV clergy disciplinary complaint against Machowski, and Anglican Watch has agreed to provide technical and pastoral support throughout the process should they so desire.

Our theological understanding

Assuming the allegations to be true, Anglican Watch categorically rejects the notion that adultery is consistent with church teaching, regardless of sexual orientation.

To be clear: All of our tiny, all-volunteer staff is LGBTQ+. We fully support same-sex marriage. And we recognize that legally unmarried couples can form holy and sacramental bonds through lifelong mutual commitment, service, and monogamy.

That said, while we support extending the blessings of monogamy and commitment to all couples, our beliefs are consistent with those of the Episcopal Church. Specifically, we reject the notion that random sexual encounters are appropriate in the context of marriage, even if the sex is consensual. We recognize marriage as a sacramental rite and a sacred vow. 

Moreover, the Title IV clergy disciplinary canons expressly claim (albeit often without justification) that clergy are, by virtue of their ordination, held to a higher standard. And while the Title IV canons often are laughably ineffective at dealing with clergy misconduct that doesn’t involve sex or money, our experience is that the one thing that will usually get clergy in serious trouble is adultery.

Thus, we expect LGBTQ+ clergy to be held to the same standard as straight clergy.

In this instance, the allegations about Machowski cover the time he was married to another man, whose name we are withholding on the basis that he is the victim of abuse. (To be clear: Machowski’s former husband is not our source.)

The allegations include conduct both before and after Machowski’s ordination as a priest. (Which raises the question: How on this green earth did Machowski get through the discernment process without someone raising the issue of his alleged sexcapades?)

Full disclosure

We also need to be upfront about another aspect of this case. Specifically, we have been aware of allegations about Machowski’s alleged infidelity for many years, but have not reported on them until now.

So, why have we ignored these allegations for so long?

The reason is that, while we have pretty good antennae and a nose for trouble, no one’s ever come forward until now. Thus, there’s been nothing actionable to report, even though we’ve been watching Machowski and quietly taking notes for a very long time.

We’re also aware that the Episcopal Church has not exactly been kind to Machowski’s ex-husband. Indeed, Machowski has largely been protected — even when he purportedly came down with one of the earliest cases of sexually transmitted monkeypox among gay men in the United States. And yet there appears to be little, if any, pastoral care for Machowski’s former husband.

To be clear, this is wrong.

Marriage among same-sex couples should be treated with the same respect as marriage by heterosexual couples. This is doubly the case when one spouse is clergy, which imposes added strains and expectations on the lay spouse.

The Grace Connection

We also want to flag an important issue in all of this: Machowski comes from Grace Episcopal in Alexandria, the church he served when he was first ordained.

That’s important because, in our experience, toxic churches like Grace produce toxic people. And Grace has a long history of narcissistic abuse and misconduct, including:

  1. Narcissistic conduct by previous rector Edward Merrow.
  2. Narcissistic abuse, including spiritual abuse, failure to protect church funds, payroll theft, perjury, and other criminal conduct, by former rector Robert Malm.
  3. A successful Title IV complaint against former assistant rector Leslie Steffensen that addressed issues involving her integrity.
  4. Abuse of former associate rectors by Malm, resulting in the abrupt departure of several, including Fanny Belanger. Both the Diocese and the Grace vestry ignored these issues, despite receiving formal complaints.
  5. Adultery and dishonesty by current rector Anne Turner. (To be clear: Her claim that her road trips with her adulterous paramour were “spiritual retreats” was a lie told to vestry members and parishioners. Turner has yet to apologize or make reparations for this conduct.)
  6. Inappropriate conduct by former Grace assistant rector Santiago Rodriguez involving boundary violations with persons under his pastoral care.

We bring this up because, far too often, the default in the Episcopal Church when confronted with allegations of abuse is to clutch the pearls, feign horror, and paper everything over with a layer of “all churchy nice.”

Ordination of Matthew Machowski, accompanied by Grace Episcopal Alexandria parishioner Mary Stewart
Ordination of Matthew Machowski, accompanied by Grace Episcopal Alexandria parishioner Mary Stewart. Source: Screen cap from MatthewMachowski.com

The problem with this approach is that, by failing to disclose misconduct, we empower it to live on. And it does, with the trauma and dysfunction simmering right beneath the surface, often for decades, even as it periodically explodes into view.

In other words, there is a disturbingly high level of clergy misconduct among persons connected with Grace Church.

Nor are things any better when it comes to laity; for many years, Malm’s strategy for dealing with a known pedophile at the parish was to be pointedly rude to him.

To be clear, being rude is not an acceptable child protection strategy, and doubly so when the pedophile in question is a member of the church, has 24/7 access to the building, and access to children.

Meanwhile, we are unimpressed with current rector Anne Turner, who talks a good game, but whose tenure is already marked by unhappy staff, extensive turnover, and continuing childish and hateful behavior by parishioners. Moreover, Turner’s own moral failings, which include adultery and lying, leave her unqualified to lead, either by word or example.

What next for Machowski?

Given the vagaries of the Episcopal Church’s Title IV clergy disciplinary process, it’s always a dangerous proposition to predict the outcome of complaints against clergy. Indeed, far too many intake officers and Title IV reference panels will bend over backwards to find excuses to avoid dealing with complaints about clergy misconduct.

That said, we believe that all clergy should be able, both in word and deed, to uphold Episcopal theology, including the sanctity of marriage and the need to respect the dignity of every human being. To be clear, random casual sex with strangers by a priest repudiates every aspect of the church’s theology, including the Baptismal Covenant.

Thus, when Machowski marries a couple, regardless of the genders of those involved, he is living a lie when he talks about “forsaking all others, until death do us part.” Relatedly, we have identified several online hookup accounts that we believe to be Machowski’s, which means his behavior likely is bringing discredit to his parish and the larger church.

That is unacceptable, and Machowski needs to be suspended immediately and ultimately defrocked. And if he hopes to find reconciliation with those he has hurt, it starts with repentance, amendment of life, and restitution. That is a Christian perspective and must be the one applied here.

As things stand, we have zero respect for Machowski’s behavior or anyone who enables it. And if needed, we will wade further into this situation to obtain justice and accountability, including filing our own Title IV complaint against him.

2 thoughts on “Source alleges dozens of instances of adultery by openly gay Episcopal priest Matthew Machowski, rector of St. Stephen’s Episcopal, Coconut Grove, Florida”

  1. I’m very familiar with Machowski and his behavior. My take is that he’s a sex addict and a manipulative, narcissistic POS. He has serious integrity issues.

    Reply
  2. Yup, sounds like sex addiction.

    But beyond that—there is a culture of willful blindness about adultery among non-straight clergy which I think is a legacy of refusing ordination to openly GLBT folks for so many decades. So some GLBT clergy chose to marry straight and have other relationships on the down low or to not marry and to keep sexual relationships a secret. That is a devastating way to live, and the church quietly condoned it for a long time. I am a gay man, and I celebrate when clergy, gay or straight, live with integrity and according to their promises to God.

    Also, mutually agreed upon “open marriages,” and consensual polyamorous configurations are not Christian marriages, and they should not be viable alternatives for straight or gay clergy in the Episcopal Church.

    Prayers ascending for this guy’s ex and for all who have been harmed by his physically dangerous risk taking and all who have been hurt by the emotional toll of his sexual behavior.

    Reply

Leave a comment