Canon Mark Anderson is asking his wife for alimony to maintain his standard of living, according to filings obtained while his divorce records were publicly available.
At St. John’s Cathedral in Jacksonville, Anderson and the dean, the Very Rev. Kate Moorehead Carroll, discuss tithing as part of a pledge campaign that asks parishioners to give an additional percentage point of their income. Those who gave 3% in 2026 are asked to give 4% in 2027.
For a Jacksonville-area household earning the median income, that extra percentage point comes to about $800 a year. That’s close to the amount Anderson budgets each month for vacations, including trips to Charlotte to see his girlfriend. The cathedral is specific about what parishioners should add to their pledges. Anderson can be just as specific about what he’s prepared to cut from his own budget before asking his wife to help maintain his lavish lifestyle.
“Is it all about you? Or do you understand that you have an obligation to others?” Anderson asked from the pulpit. In his divorce case, that obligation seems to run the other way.
Interestingly, Jesus warned about religious teachers who lay heavy burdens on others and refuse to lift a finger themselves. “They do not practice what they preach,” Jesus said.
What the cathedral already provides
Anderson’s estimated $200,000 in annual pay and benefits is about 2.5 times the Jacksonville metro area’s median household income of $79,643.
His financial affidavit lists six-figure gross income, a substantial clergy housing allowance, and a Church Pension Fund plan. The housing allowance is eligible for a federal income tax exclusion. Anderson testified that the cathedral pays for his health insurance. His affidavit lists a paltry amount of federal, state, and local income taxes under monthly deductions.
Based on Anglican Watch’s earlier review of that publicly filed affidavit, Anderson’s reported rent works out to about three times Jacksonville’s median gross rent. His reported clergy housing allowance was roughly seven times the city median.
If the cathedral already provides what Anderson needs to live, what justifies asking his wife to help maintain his lavish lifestyle while urging parishioners to give a larger share of their own income?
In sworn testimony, Anderson identified Jana Angel as his girlfriend and said his vacation budget includes trips to Charlotte, where she lives. He testified that he flew there with the son he shares with his wife to visit Angel for part of Mother’s Day weekend. He and his son had previously stayed overnight at her home, he said. Anderson also testified that he took a cruise with Angel and could not recall exactly where they went or which port they left from.
As we previously reported, Angel featured Anderson on News4JAX’s River City Live in a segment promoting the cathedral’s pet blessing. The published coverage made no mention of a personal relationship. Covering her own boyfriend would be an obvious conflict of interest that viewers deserved to know about.
Episcopal marriage vows call for fidelity. In a separate case, the Church’s Court of Review upheld a finding of clergy misconduct against the Rev. Daniel W. McClain, a Dayton, Ohio, priest, for admitted adultery while his divorce was pending.
Anderson has told the court that visits to Angel are part of his vacation budget. Does a priest expect his wife to pay for trips to see his girlfriend?
Vow of poverty. What sacrifice?
Members of Episcopal religious orders customarily take a formal vow of poverty and agree to hold possessions in common or in trust. At ordination, a parish priest promises to do his best to pattern his life and household on Christ’s teaching and to be “a wholesome example.”
“Sell your possessions and give to the poor,” Jesus tells his disciples in Luke’s Gospel. Then-Presiding Bishop Michael Curry put it plainly in a 2024 sermon. “Do what you can to make poverty history.”
If the cathedral already meets his needs, what moral claim does he have on his wife’s income to maintain a lavish lifestyle? Is that the example a man of God is supposed to set? Is Anderson saying that God has not provided sufficiently for him? If so, his parishioners deserve to know.
A gift at the bank. A loan in court?
Anderson is no stranger to asking others for money, not just parishioners. He is now asking a divorce judge to make his wife repay part of the $1 million his father told their mortgage lender was a gift. The money helped the couple buy their former home, which Anglican Watch previously reported was worth about $4 million.
In an October letter to the lender, Anderson’s father said the money had gone into the couple’s joint account. “This is not a loan,” he wrote.
Anderson’s attorneys interestingly cite a loan agreement between him and his father dated in August, nearly two months before the gift letter. Their memorandum says his father provided the letter to help the couple obtain financing. In his deposition, Anderson said, “There was never $1 million gifted to us.” The same memorandum quotes his wife’s testimony that Anderson told her the down payment was a gift.
Anglican Watch previously questioned whether the loan and gift letter misrepresented the transfer to the lender and reported that it filed a clergy disciplinary complaint with the Diocese of Florida. The Episcopal Church’s disciplinary rules, known as Title IV, require clergy to refrain from “conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation.” If the agreement was already in place in August, why did the lender receive a letter in October saying the money was a gift? In the father’s deposition, he admitted to gifting the money.
The questions he asked from the pulpit
In an October sermon, Anderson asked his congregation to consider what they wanted to accomplish in a dispute. “Are we trying to beat them? Are we trying to humiliate them?”
A review of Anderson’s divorce docket, while it was still publicly available, counted more than a couple hundred documents and found that most substantive filings came from his side. By comparison, the full docket in Dean Carroll’s 2019 divorce contained close to a quarter of the number of filings, according to a separate tally. Anderson sought to seal records in his case, and Anglican Watch opposed the request.
What did Anderson hope to accomplish with those filings? Was he pursuing a scorched-earth legal strategy?
Before you sign the pledge card
Parishioners asked to give more should ask how much of their giving goes toward clergy pay and benefits and what example their vicar sets in his own household.
Anderson wants them to make a bigger pledge. He can show them how he’s keeping the one he made at ordination.
Related coverage
- Mark Anderson’s divorce testimony and questions about the mortgage transaction
- Mark Anderson, Jana Angel, and the undisclosed News4JAX relationship
- Disciplinary complaint and additional concerns involving Anderson
- Anglican Watch opposes Anderson’s attempt to seal divorce records
- Clergy housing allowances and federal tax treatment

