Church budgets shouldn’t require a leap of faith

Churches ask parishioners to give generously, trust their leaders, and support their ministries. But when it comes to explaining where the money went, more than a few seem to believe transparency is a one-way street—and they’re standing on the side of the road with their hand out.

At Anglican Watch, we think that’s backwards. Churches should be among the most financially transparent institutions in their communities, not places where parishioners have to corner the treasurer at coffee hour to find out how their pledge is being spent.

Yet at many parishes, financial disclosure amounts to three pie charts at the annual meeting, a few reassuring words from the rector, and a reminder that stewardship season is right around the corner.

Splendid. But where did the money actually go?

Financial transparency shouldn’t be a favor granted to the unusually persistent. It should be standard operating procedure, with meaningful financial information posted online where anyone can find it.

Here’s what every church should be doing.

Publish a detailed, line-item budget

Every church should publish its annual operating budget with enough detail to show where the money goes. Categories like “administration,” “ministry,” and “building” aren’t informative when they conceal six-figure sums.

A useful budget distinguishes among:

  • Clergy compensation, including salary, housing, pension, health insurance, and other benefits.
  • Lay employee compensation and benefits, grouped by function.
  • Building expenses, including utilities, insurance, cleaning, maintenance, repairs, and capital improvements.
  • Worship, music, Christian education, and youth ministry.
  • Outreach, charitable grants, and direct financial assistance.
  • Diocesan assessments and other denominational payments.
  • Administration, technology, professional services, and governance.
  • Debt service, reserve contributions, and endowment withdrawals.

The budget should show prior-year actuals alongside current-year projections and proposed spending. Explain significant changes in plain English, not accountant-ese.

Individual employee pay may warrant confidentiality. Aggregate compensation does not. And senior clergy compensation deserves meaningful disclosure, consistent with applicable law and privacy obligations. If the rector’s package is defensible, it will survive scrutiny.

Churches should also separate spending on actual ministry from the cost of keeping the institution alive. A budget that lumps everything into “personnel” and “programs” may satisfy an accountant, but it tells parishioners roughly nothing.

Put it online

Financial documents shouldn’t be available only to people who attend the annual meeting, know a vestry member, or are stubborn enough to keep asking.

Every church should maintain a public financial transparency page with current and historical budgets, annual financial statements, audit reports, and other significant disclosures.

That doesn’t mean posting donor names, personnel files, pastoral assistance records, bank account numbers, or security-sensitive information. Reasonable redactions are appropriate.

But confidentiality exists to protect legitimate private interests, not to shield institutional decisions from scrutiny.

If a church can post 47 photos of the parish picnic, it can post its budget.

Publish real audits—and account for every dollar

A budget tells parishioners what leaders intend to spend. An audit helps establish what actually happened.

Canon I.7.1(f) of The Episcopal Church requires that all parish accounts be audited annually—by an independent CPA, an independent licensed public accountant, or an audit committee authorized by the appropriate diocesan authority. The church’s Manual of Business Methods in Church Affairs fills in the details on controls, reporting, and audit procedures.

But not all financial examinations are created equal.

Many dioceses permit agreed-upon procedures (AUP) engagements to satisfy the requirement. An AUP engagement is not an audit. It provides no opinion and no assurance of any kind. Under the AICPA’s AT-C Section 215, the practitioner performs a list of specified procedures and reports what was found—full stop. No opinion. No conclusion. No statement that the books are accurate, complete, or free of material misstatement.

Yes, an AUP engagement is technically an attestation engagement. It also isn’t what anyone means when they say “audit.”

Calling it one doesn’t magically make it one. Neither does putting “audit” in the committee’s name.

Vestries should receive and review both the engagement letter and the final report, including any management letter flagging weaknesses in internal controls. The engagement letter states what the examiner agreed to review; the report states what they found. If the vestry has seen neither, it doesn’t know what the “audit” covered—and it certainly can’t tell parishioners. Document the review and any corrective action in the minutes.

And the examination should cover the church’s entire financial operation, not just the main checking account.

That means operating funds, restricted gifts, memorial funds, clergy discretionary funds, investments, endowments, capital campaigns, and every account maintained by every parish organization, from the altar guild to the men’s breakfast. Record and oversee all church-controlled money, even when a particular account falls outside the scope of a given engagement.

No off-budget accounts. No unofficial funds. No bank account someone conveniently forgot to mention.

The same goes for parish schools. When a school operates as part of the parish rather than as a separate legal entity, the vestry should receive and review its budgets, financial statements, liabilities, and significant commitments.

Even when the school is separately incorporated, the vestry needs to understand the church’s exposure: shared property, subsidies, loans, guarantees, insurance, and other obligations. How much oversight is required, and whether the finances must be consolidated, depends on the governing documents, the legal relationships, and applicable accounting standards.

But if the church owns the building, pays some of the bills, or holds the liabilities, announcing that the school’s finances are “none of the vestry’s business” is a creative reading of fiduciary duty. We’d love to hear the diocesan chancellor explain it.

Churches should publish their financial statements and final reports, subject to appropriate redactions. Where an AUP engagement or audit committee review was done instead of an independent financial-statement audit, say so. Clearly.

And announcing that the parish “passed its audit” is not financial reporting. An audit isn’t a driving test. Parishioners deserve more than a thumbs-up from the pulpit.

No church should have money that is invisible to its own governing body.

Publish vestry minutes

Vestries make decisions about finances, property, staffing, and priorities. Parishioners should be able to see how their elected representatives are handling the job.

Approved vestry minutes should be published promptly—within 30 days of approval—including significant motions, recorded votes, and major financial decisions.

That means budget approvals, substantial expenditures, borrowing, property transactions, and changes in financial policy.

Personnel matters, privileged legal advice, safeguarding information, and genuine pastoral concerns may justify executive session or limited redactions. But executive session shouldn’t become a black hole where every inconvenient decision disappears. If a vestry goes into executive session more often than it comes out, something is wrong.

When the vestry approves significant spending outside the adopted budget, it should explain what changed and why. Parishioners shouldn’t have to learn how their church is governed from the parking lot rumor mill.

Tell parishioners how much actually goes to ministry

The most revealing question in church budgeting is also the one least often answered:

How much of the money supports ministry, and how much goes to salaries, buildings, administration, and keeping the lights on?

The line isn’t always clean. Clergy salaries support worship and pastoral care, but also a good deal of administration. Buildings house ministry, but can devour staggering sums in utilities, insurance, and repairs.

So churches should publish a functional breakdown—direct ministry, administration, facilities, governance—and explain how shared costs are allocated.

This isn’t exotic. The Financial Accounting Standards Board already requires nonprofits that follow its standards to report expenses by both nature and function. Churches are generally exempt from the filing requirements that force other nonprofits to disclose. That’s a legal privilege, not a moral one.

We’re not suggesting clergy work for free or that churches bulldoze their buildings. We’re suggesting parishioners deserve to know what their money accomplishes.

If 80 percent of spending goes to personnel and property, that may be a legitimate choice. But it should be an informed choice, not a fact buried under cheerful labels.

And churches should be especially candid when an aging building is eating the outreach budget alive.

Disclose conflicts of interest and major transactions

Churches should have written conflict-of-interest policies requiring clergy, vestry members, and other decision-makers to disclose relevant financial and personal relationships—and should actually enforce them.

Transactions involving relatives, businesses owned by church leaders, consulting contracts, and real estate deserve independent scrutiny. The senior warden’s brother-in-law may well be the best roofer in town. Prove it.

Major expenditures and property transactions should involve competitive bidding (or a documented reason for skipping it), independent valuation where appropriate, and approval by disinterested decision-makers.

Vestry minutes should record disclosures, recusals, and approvals.

Related entities count, too. If a church controls a foundation, property-holding company, or LLC, those finances and transactions need real oversight and appropriate disclosure.

Moving a building into an LLC doesn’t make the money disappear from parish scrutiny. It just makes it harder to find—which, we suspect, is sometimes the point. And where a transaction requires diocesan approval, parishioners should be told whether that approval was actually obtained, not just assumed.

Report results throughout the year

An annual budget is a starting point, not a reporting system.

Churches should publish quarterly reports comparing actual income and spending with the adopted budget, flagging significant variances and emerging risks.

Those reports should cover pledge income, cash reserves, debt, restricted funds, and reliance on endowment withdrawals.

Churches running recurring deficits should disclose realistic projections and explain how leadership plans to fix the problem—not just pray harder.

And no, covering the operating shortfall with “extraordinary” endowment withdrawals three years running isn’t financial sustainability. It’s a slow-motion going-out-of-business sale.

Transparency builds donor trust

There’s a practical reason to do all this: donors care where their money goes.

Independent Sector’s 2026 national survey of 3,000 U.S. adults, conducted with Edelman Data & Intelligence, found that 74 percent said transparency about how nonprofits use their funds would positively affect their trust. Another 73 percent said the same about transparency regarding funding sources.

Research from the Charity Commission for England and Wales and the BBB Wise Giving Alliance’s donor trust reports point in the same direction: donors want to know where the money goes and whether they can trust the people spending it.

These studies concern nonprofits generally, not Episcopal parishes specifically, and they don’t prove that posting a budget raises pledges. But they support an unremarkable conclusion: Financial disclosure matters to donors.

Every rector and vestry gearing up for stewardship season might want to sit with that.

Churches spend enormous energy encouraging generosity, explaining why ministry costs money, and asking parishioners to increase their pledges. Yet some remain oddly reluctant to disclose where those pledges went.

There’s a certain irony in asking parishioners to demonstrate their faith through financial generosity while declining to demonstrate institutional accountability through financial disclosure.

If churches want parishioners to trust them with their money, they might start by trusting parishioners with the numbers.

Make accountability part of the culture

Transparency isn’t just posting documents. It requires a culture in which parishioners can ask reasonable questions without being brushed off, embarrassed, or accused of disloyalty. “Why do you want to know?” is not an answer. It’s a tell.

Vestry members should receive financial training, understand their fiduciary duties, and have access to the records needed for real oversight. A vestry that rubber-stamps the treasurer’s report because nobody wants to look difficult isn’t governing. It’s attending.

Churches should maintain confidential channels for reporting suspected financial misconduct, with protection against retaliation and procedures for independent investigation.

And when errors surface, leaders should acknowledge them, fix them, and explain what will prevent a repeat. Not circle the wagons.

The goal isn’t to turn every parishioner into a forensic accountant. It’s to make sure ordinary members can understand their church’s finances without needing one.

Trust requires transparency

Churches describe stewardship as a spiritual obligation. They’re right. But stewardship isn’t just the responsibility of the people writing the checks. It’s the responsibility of the people cashing them.

The canons set a floor, not a ceiling. Canonical compliance and meaningful transparency are not the same thing, and a parish that confuses the two has already told you something.

None of this is radical. Publish the budget. Share the financial statements. Disclose what kind of examination you actually had and what it didn’t cover. Publish the minutes. Explain major transactions. Show how much money goes to ministry versus institutional maintenance.

No off-budget accounts, no blind spots involving parish schools, and no pretending money is exempt from oversight because someone gave it a different name.

And when parishioners ask questions, answer them.

Because “trust us” isn’t a financial control. And secrecy isn’t a ministry.

Sources

  • The Episcopal Church, Constitution and Canons, Title I, Canon 7. Establishes annual audit requirements for parish, mission, and diocesan accounts and permitted audit methods. Read the Constitution and Canons.
  • The Episcopal Church, Manual of Business Methods in Church Affairs (2023). Chapters I, II, V, VI, and IX address financial management, internal controls, discretionary funds, audits, and records. Chapter VI addresses off-the-books accounts, audit reports, and vestry receipt of audit findings. Read the manual.
  • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, AT-C Section 215, Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements. Explains why practitioners report procedures and findings without providing an opinion or assurance. Read the standard.
  • Independent Sector, Trust in Nonprofits and Philanthropy (July 2026). National survey of 3,000 U.S. adults, conducted with Edelman Data & Intelligence, finding that 74% say transparency about fund usage positively affects trust, and 73% say the same about funding sources. Read the research.
  • Episcopal Church Foundation, financial oversight resources. Practical guidance for treasurers, parish administrators, and vestries. View the resources.
  • The Episcopal Diocese of Olympia, Financial Audits. Summarizes canonical requirements for annual audits and submission of audit reports and internal-control findings. Read the diocesan guidance.
  • Financial Accounting Standards Board, ASU 2016-14, Presentation of Financial Statements of Not-for-Profit Entities. Requires nonprofits to present expenses by both nature and function. View the accounting standards.
  • Charity Commission for England and Wales, research on public trust in charities. View the research.
  • BBB Wise Giving Alliance, Donor Trust Reports. View the reports.

Leave a comment