Three recent disciplinary rulings in the Church of England provide a striking contrast with the dismal administration of clergy discipline in The Episcopal Church (TEC).
One priest has been permanently prohibited from ministry for coercive and controlling behavior and the exploitation of a vulnerable woman. Another has been removed from office for neglecting his parish responsibilities and taking excess annual leave. A former bishop has been formally found responsible for misconduct after admitting failures in handling safeguarding disclosures.
The cases differ considerably. What they share is a documented disciplinary process, published findings and, in two cases, substantial penalties. Meanwhile, TEC continues to struggle with the basics of its Title IV clergy disciplinary system: timely investigations, meaningful pastoral responses, compliance with its own canons and accountability for bishops.
The Church of England has its own appalling record of safeguarding failures. Nobody should mistake these rulings for evidence that its problems have been solved. But the contrast with TEC is nevertheless difficult to ignore.
Jonathan Douglas: lifetime ban for coercive control and exploitation
On November 11, a disciplinary tribunal in the Diocese of Rochester removed the Rev. Jonathan Douglas from office and permanently prohibited him from exercising ordained ministry.
The tribunal found that Douglas engaged in coercive and controlling behavior toward his former wife over more than two years, causing serious emotional, psychological and spiritual harm. It also found that Douglas exploited a vulnerable woman who had sought his pastoral counsel during the breakdown of her marriage. Their relationship became sexually intimate, with the tribunal concluding that Douglas took advantage of her emotional attachment to him and violated appropriate pastoral boundaries.
The tribunal considered evidence from parishioners praising Douglas’s ministry, including accounts of congregational growth and effective pastoral leadership. But it rejected the notion that his public accomplishments outweighed his private misconduct. Indeed, the tribunal observed that coercive behavior within intimate relationships frequently goes unrecognized by outsiders.
The tribunal found his former wife’s testimony compelling and rejected his suggestion that the proceedings were retaliation for earlier complaints about diocesan practices. It also considered evidence of concealment, including secrecy and deleted messages, and concluded that his limited acknowledgment of wrongdoing offered no realistic basis for believing he could safely return to ministry.
The result was removal from office and a lifetime prohibition. Notably, the published decision explains the evidence, credibility assessments and reasoning. It also protects the identity of the vulnerable woman without concealing the misconduct.
There is no mystery about the outcome. The church published its findings and imposed a serious penalty.
Melusi Sibanda: neglecting parishioners is misconduct
In the Diocese of Leeds, a disciplinary tribunal found that the Rev. Melusi Sibanda repeatedly neglected fundamental responsibilities at the parishes of Heckmondwike and Liversedge.
The findings included failures to attend services and meetings, inadequate pastoral care, neglect of bereaved families, failures in parish administration and excessive annual leave. Sibanda also failed to engage adequately with church schools, parish leadership and his bishop. The tribunal found that his conduct amounted to neglect or inefficiency in the performance of his duties under the Clergy Discipline Measure 2003.
Sibanda did not attend the proceedings or provide the requested medical evidence supporting his stated inability to participate. The tribunal considered whether an adjournment was warranted before proceeding in his absence.
The tribunal concluded that the failures were sustained and went to the heart of his responsibilities as a parish priest. It subsequently removed him from office, prohibited him from ministry for three years and required him to submit a written reflection on his responsibilities before the prohibition expired.
This case is particularly instructive for TEC. In our experience, Episcopal dioceses frequently treat pastoral neglect as an administrative inconvenience rather than a serious failure of ordained ministry. Complaints are delayed, minimized or dismissed, sometimes with little meaningful engagement with those affected.
The Church of England tribunal took a different approach. It heard evidence, evaluated the harm to parishioners and concluded that neglect of fundamental pastoral responsibilities constituted misconduct. Imagine that.
Paul Butler: bishops can be held accountable, too
Perhaps the most significant comparison involves the former Bishop of Durham, Paul Butler.
On November 10, the Vicar-General’s Court of the Province of York formally found Butler responsible for misconduct following his admissions concerning safeguarding disclosures related to the late serial abuser John Smyth. Butler acknowledged failures to take sufficient action following two disclosures made to him in 2015, including failing to ensure that safeguarding professionals received the information.
The court recorded a formal finding of misconduct. A penalty hearing is scheduled for December 14, so no final sanction has yet been imposed.
The case is noteworthy because Butler was not accused of personally committing Smyth’s abuse. His misconduct consisted of failing to respond appropriately to information about abuse. That principle should be familiar to TEC, where bishops bear responsibility for safeguarding, pastoral response and administration of the church’s disciplinary canons.
Yet our experience is that Episcopal bishops and senior disciplinary officials can repeatedly fail to follow Title IV with few meaningful consequences. The Butler proceedings demonstrate that failures of oversight can themselves be grounds for discipline. A bishop does not have to commit the original abuse to bear responsibility for mishandling it.
TEC officials continue to ignore church canons
As Anglican Watch has previously documented, three successive officials responsible for handling Title IV complaints against bishops—Clay Matthews, Todd Ousley, and Barb Kempf—have, in our experience, effectively rewritten the disciplinary canons to suit their own preferences.
The problems have included unauthorized factual determinations during intake, inadequate communication, prolonged delays and failures to provide required pastoral responses. Even the most basic requirements are routinely ignored.
Canon IV.8.1 requires a bishop diocesan to provide for an appropriate pastoral response whenever a report is made to an intake officer. This requirement is mandatory, not optional, and does not depend on whether a complaint ultimately results in disciplinary charges. The 2024 General Convention amendments further strengthened the requirement by mandating a professional pastoral care assessment when a report involves alleged sexual misconduct.
Yet dioceses including Florida and Virginia have, in cases documented by Anglican Watch, failed to comply with the pastoral-response requirement.
Nor does a pastoral response mean merely offering a complainant a few counseling sessions or sending an occasional reassuring email. The canons contemplate a response directed toward healing, restitution, justice, amendment of life and reconciliation among affected persons and communities. Importantly, pastoral response and pastoral care are not interchangeable. A pastoral response is the broader canonical obligation; pastoral care is one component that may be offered to those affected.
Those are substantive obligations, not public-relations exercises.
Our review of Title IV outcomes identified recurring problems with communication, procedural compliance and the treatment of complainants. We have also documented myriad instances in which the intake officer or Reference Panel appeared to make factual determinations properly reserved for later stages of the disciplinary process.
In short, the church has detailed disciplinary canons. What it often lacks is the willingness to follow them.
Transparency is part of accountability
Another distinction is the availability of actual disciplinary decisions. The Church of England has published detailed tribunal findings explaining what happened, what evidence was considered and why particular sanctions were imposed. The Douglas decision even demonstrates how a tribunal can protect a vulnerable person’s identity while publicly explaining its conclusions.
TEC, by contrast, frequently invokes confidentiality while providing little meaningful information about the handling or disposition of complaints. Confidentiality is necessary to protect complainants, witnesses and sensitive information. It should not become a convenient means of concealing institutional failures.
And while TEC has announced a Title IV reform pilot under Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe, the initiative has yet to establish that the church can consistently administer its existing canons.
New procedures, additional staff and increased spending may help. But none is a substitute for holding bishops and disciplinary officials accountable when they ignore the rules.
Nor is transparency alone sufficient. The Church of England publishes detailed decisions in cases that reach its tribunals, but many complaints never reach that stage. Published decisions are evidence of accountability in particular cases, not proof that the entire system works.
The Church of England is hardly a model institution
To be clear, the Church of England’s broader safeguarding record remains deeply troubling. Its failures in the Smyth scandal demonstrate the consequences of institutional deference, secrecy and the unwillingness of senior church leaders to confront abuse. Nor are three disciplinary decisions sufficient to establish that one denomination’s disciplinary system consistently performs better than another’s.
But these rulings illustrate principles that TEC should find unremarkable: allegations can be examined through documented proceedings, misconduct can be established on the evidence, senior clergy can be held accountable and the public can be told why decisions were reached.
Perhaps most importantly, the Douglas case demonstrates that successful ministry, popularity and supportive parishioners do not excuse misconduct. The Sibanda case establishes that sustained pastoral neglect is a disciplinary matter. And the Butler case makes clear that senior church leaders may face discipline for failing to respond appropriately to allegations of abuse.
These should not be remarkable developments. They should be routine.
The Episcopal Church has spent years discussing accountability, transparency and safeguarding. Perhaps it should spend more time actually delivering them.
In these three cases, the Church of England has demonstrated that clergy discipline can produce findings, consequences and a public record. For TEC, even that modest standard sometimes appears to be a bridge too far.
Related coverage
- What other churches can teach TEC about clergy discipline
- United Methodists admit misconduct complaints are ignored. Now comes the hard part.
Sources
- Church of England — disciplinary tribunal decisions — Official register of published tribunal determinations and penalties.
- Jonathan Douglas — tribunal determination — Findings on coercive control, vulnerability, witness credibility and pastoral misconduct.
- Jonathan Douglas — penalty determination — Lifetime prohibition and removal from office.
- Melusi Sibanda — tribunal decision — Findings of sustained neglect of parish responsibilities.
- Paul Butler — November 10 ruling — Misconduct finding arising from failures to act on safeguarding disclosures.
- General Convention Resolution 2024-A053 — Amendments to pastoral-response requirements under Title IV.
- Anglican Watch — Title IV disciplinary outcomes — Previous analysis of disciplinary procedural deficiencies.







