Southall Church/Grace Chapel former employee Paul aka Jay Tremblay charged with embezzling more than $350,000 in church funds

As one reader puts it, “You can’t make this stuff up.” And they are exactly right, even as we receive news that long-time Steve Berger insider and Grace Chapel/Southall Church employee Paul Tremblay has been arrested and charged with embezzling more than $350,000 during the course of his nine years’ employment with the church.

The news is the latest in the ongoing saga of corruption and abuse at Grace Chapel (aka Southall Church) formerly led by Christian nationalist pastor Steve Berger — who now shares a home in Washington, DC, with House Speaker Mike Johnson.

Why is Anglican Watch covering this story, given its lack of connection with our focus on the Episcopal Church?

The answer is that we continue to support Angie, Gracie, and Grant Solomon in their efforts to find justice after years of alleged abuse. The alleged abuse includes sexual, emotional, and physical abuse, both at home and via their connections with Grace Chapel/Steve Berger.

Additionally, we remain deeply concerned about the questionable circumstances of Grant Solomon’s death while in the custody of his father, former WSMV sports anchor Aaron Solomon.

Aaron Solomon looking for sex
Aaron Solomon looking for sex — and allegedly using his daughter’s photo as part of the gig

Many of our concerns about Grace Chapel extend to Grace Christian Academy, where Grant was a standout baseball player.

Specifically, school officials brushed off complaints by Grant and Gracie Solomon that Gracie was being abused by her father, Aaron Solomon.

Moreover, school officials, including former school counselor Amy Blaylock Curle, knew of the allegations but refused to fulfill their obligations as mandated reporters under Tennessee law. In Curle’s case, she refused to do so, despite being ordered by the courts to fulfill her obligation. (We also have been unable to substantiate various aspects of Curle’s claimed professional credentials.)

Curle also appears to be the Queen of Gaslighting, having told Gracie to stop claiming that she was being abused, for fear of Gracie “ruining her reputation.”

We were not aware that being abused was a legitimate basis for criticizing victims and question the professional judgment (not to mention sanity) of anyone who postures the issue in these terms.

Thus, despite Berger’s departure from Grace Chapel and its subsequent rebrand, we have long viewed the Grace Chapel and Grace Christian School as a den of vipers.

There are also several related issues:

  1. All churches should be aware of the risk of embezzlement. Approximately one in three churches eventually experiences fraud, accounting for about 6 percent of all donated church funds. Notably, fraud is more common in denominations with a multi-parish structure.
  2. The so-called “fraud triangle” applies here. Consisting of pressure, opportunity, and rationalization, these three factors appear in almost every case of embezzlement. In this instance, we are left asking, “How the Sam heck can Grace Chapel take nine years to spot $350,000 in missing funds?” This delay in spotting the allegedly missing money makes it clear that Grace Chapel’s internal controls are seriously deficient, and Paul and Patti Tremblay have a long history of displaying warning signs of impending trouble, including tax liens, financial problems, and more. In other words, Grace Chapel has serious governance issues.

    Patti Tremblay
    Patti Tremblay
  3. As we have stated previously, we are deeply concerned about Patti Tremblay’s potential role in the death of Grant Solomon. Specifically, under normal circumstances, it is improbable that Patti would approach Grant Solomon to invite him to meet with Berger, who positions himself as a VIP and is famously reluctant to meet people he doesn’t see as movers and shakers. Nor is it plausible that Grant — who died in mysterious circumstances just weeks later — would meet with Berger to ask “how to get closer to Jesus.”
  4. As to Grace Chapel’s claims that it did not ignore Gracie’s pleas for help, those statements are lies. Indeed, despite numerous FOIA and other investigatory requests, we have never seen ANY evidence that the church or school fulfilled their obligations as mandated reporters. Nor has Rob Rogers responded to our multiple requests for comment. Thus, we see no reason to treat anything Grace Chapel/Southall Church says as credible.
  5. We continue to question Rob Rogers’ claims of miraculous deliverance from addiction. While we are open to the notion that God can, indeed, work miracles, in our experience, people with a substance use disorder struggle throughout life to maintain sobriety. Moreover, claims of unique access to God and divine miracles are primary indicators of spiritual abuse and further reinforce our distrust of the church.
  6. We are mindful of the shadowy web of organizations that funnel money to Steve Berger and his Christian nationalist causes, which we have explored extensively in previous posts. Again, this adds to our unease over anything to do with Grace Chapel.
  7. Given the extent of Tremblay’s alleged theft, it is difficult to believe that Patti Tremblay was unaware. As in, what on earth do you do with $350,000, beyond paying off IRS tax liens?
  8. Finally, we recall that the Tremblays appear to have a convicted child sex offender in the family. While we recognize the dangers of imputing these issues to others, there are too many issues with the Tremblays for us not to suspect that there is more to this story than meets the eye.
Paul Tremblay
Paul Tremblay’s father is a registered sex offender

6 thoughts on “Southall Church/Grace Chapel former employee Paul aka Jay Tremblay charged with embezzling more than $350,000 in church funds”

  1. hey do a search on your own website for Paul Leo Tremblay – same dude as this story – aw-gets-reports-that-a-member-of-patti-tremblays-family-may-be-a-convicted-pedophile ?

    Reply
    • Hi Cole. Thanks for the tips. We were all over the link to the child sex offender cases in California, but it turns out that it’s Jay’s father, who is 81.

      Guess that explains why Jay didn’t use his real name.

      – Eric

      Reply

Leave a comment