Disclosure: Anglican Watch editor Eric Bonetti is a former member of Grace Church. Bonetti is on medical leave and had no role in the decision to cover this story or production of this article.
Grace Episcopal Church in Alexandria, Va., is again the center of controversy following a recent announcement that outgoing associate rector Santiago Rodriguez has been suspended from ordained ministry for three months in a Title IV proceeding. The news comes amid allegations that he maintained an inappropriate but non-sexual relationship with a parishioner at the church over a period of several months.
The news follows a one-year suspension of rector Anne Turner over allegations that she had an adulterous affair with a person with close ties to the parish. Turner subsequently tried to sandbag this publication’s coverage of her conduct on several bases, including a claim that the public was not entitled to know that her husband, Stephen Watts, serves as a deputy secretary of defense. (To be clear: If you are a priest, the public has the right to know that you are an adulterer. It also has the right to know that your husband has a key role in national security.)
Previously, rector Bob Malm came in for widespread criticism after he and church attorney Jeffery “Sugarland” Chiow falsely told the courts that former parishioner Eric Bonetti had threatened the church.

Chiow’s courtroom pleadings contained multiple fabrications, including that:
- Bonetti was inspired to threaten the parish by a fictional church shooting in the equally fictional town of “Sugarland Texas.”
- Bonetti was not an attorney.
- Bonetti had never served as a police officer.
Chiow made a series of related facially questionable claims to the courts, including his claim, made in writing, that his then-law firm, Rogers, Joseph, O’Donnell had devoted more than $100,000 in billable hours to the matter.
Chiow also attempted to subpoena Bonetti’s mother, then terminally ill, but was rebuffed by local courts.
Subsequently, Malm engaged in felony perjury, telling a court under oath that Bonetti had “terrorized” him and his family, despite having had no contact in over a year.
In response, more than 27,000 members of the public signed an online petition calling for Malm to be held accountable.
Relatedly, numerous members of Grace Church behaved badly in conjunction with the Malm debacle, including:
- Lisa Medley, who inappropriately (and inaccurately) disclosed confidential giving information about Bonetti and posted various lies on The Wartburg Watch about Bonetti.
- Lucy Medley, who urged Bonetti to commit suicide amidst a spate of homophobic comments.

- Rich Kelly, who, as senior warden sent an email to parishioners falsely claiming there was no truth to Bonetti’s allegations — despite the fact that Malm’s lies told during litigation made clear that Bonetti was absolutely accurate.
- Cynthia Puskar, who told Bonetti that his concerns were a “bunch of trash,” despite having no first-hand knowledge of the matter. (One wonders why Puskar would have that conversation if there were indeed reasons to believe Bonetti was actually, in the words of Sugarland Chiow, a “domestic terrorist.” But then, integrity was never Puskar’s strong suit.)
- Kelly Gable, who falsely accused Bonetti of, inter alia, being an embezzler. (These comments were made despite Bonetti’s efforts to hire Gable in order to address her ongoing inability to retain steady employment. Gable was subsequently arrested and charged with domestic violence.)

To date, no one at Grace Episcopal has taken responsibility for the church’s conduct or apologized for their behavior, and Chiow remains a welcome member of the parish despite his myriad fabrications. Thus, it is appropriate to withhold resources from the parish until it lives into the Baptismal Covenant and publicly repents of its sinful conduct. And to be clear: Jeffery Chiow and his fabrications evince someone who should have no role in parish leadership. The fact that Chiow is welcome in the church — or that Lucy Medley (who grew up in the church) doesn’t see a problem with urging people to commit suicide — bespeaks a toxic parish that may well be beyond redemption.
Meanwhile, Anglican Watch staff is aware of additional clergy misconduct at Grace that has yet to come to the Diocese’s attention.
Thus, Grace continues a multi-year pattern of abusive and untruthful conduct, including boundary violations, on the part of clergy, combined with enabling conduct on the part of lay leadership. Meanwhile, the church has yet to take these issues seriously or call in professional facilitators to help it work through its history of toxic behavior. As a result, there is every reason to believe that these issues will continue.
Kudos for disclosure
On one front, however, Anglican Watch is prepared to recognize Grace Church, including for an email earlier today in which the church disclosed the Title IV issues involving Santiago. While there were some glaring errors, including failing to reassure people that the allegations did not involve minors, disclosure is vital to healing. Indeed, experts believe that disclosure must happen on four levels, including:
- Interpersonal
- Intrapersonal
- Organizational
- Social
Thus, we believe that today’s disclosure was important, but we are concerned that there will not be adequate follow-up.
Additionally, the parish will not move past issues from Malm’s tenure — including Malm’s toxic narcissism — until it discusses those matters openly, in a safe environment, and with professional facilitation. And to be clear: Like attracts like. It is no coincidence that we continue to see clergy at Grace Church who are unwilling to maintain appropriate boundaries.
Meanwhile, Anglican Watch reiterates that there are other skeletons in Grace’s closet. Both the Diocese and members of the parish must deliberately work towards health and wholeness if they do not want to face further problems. And to be clear: It’s not that hard to act with integrity. The fact that this is such a problematic issue for Grace Church should be a wake-up call, both to the Diocese, the Grace vestry, and Anne Turner. (While they are at it, the recent churn among parish staff warrants a fulsome discussion. Suffice it to say, there is a reason for this churn.)
Our thoughts and prayers go out to all involved in this difficult situation.







