On the first anniversary of the Church of England’s Makin Report, abuse and a broken safeguarding system remain unchanged in the Episcopal Church

On the one-year anniversary of the release of the Makin Report, which detailed the Church of England’s disastrous non-response to decades of spiritual, sexual, physical, emotional and other abuse by the late barrister John Smyth, the Episcopal Church (TEC) has made almost no meaningful improvement in its own response to ongoing abuse within the denomination.

The Makin Report provides context

Our conclusion that the Episcopal Church remains woefully unresponsive when it comes to preventing and addressing abuse comes as the group monitoring implementation of the Makin Report’s proposed reforms offered a public update on progress made to date on the group’s 27 recommendations. Additionally, the group noted that many of the lessons learned in the course of its investigation are both important and beyond the scope of the group’s specific proposals.

Among the proposals implemented in the Church of England (COE):

  • Formation of an independent safeguarding commission, independent of the church hierarchy.
  • Protection for whistleblowers.
  • A requirement that all persons with knowledge of abuse report it to safeguarding officials.
  • Audits of past and present safeguarding practices across the church.
  • Creation of an independent scrutiny body to oversee church safeguarding.
  • Establishment of a single point of contact between safeguarding officials and law enforcement.
  • Elimination of the statute of limitations of church misconduct.
  • Creating a database of aspirants to ordination who have been rejected over safeguarding concerns.

Additionally, officials seek disciplinary charges against the ten clergy involved. So far, seven have been charged, including previous archbishops of Canterbury.

Meanwhile, the COE has rightly stated that it must be more accountable, more aware and responsive to the needs of survivors, and it must create a culture in which all persons are safe and welcome within the church.

(Minor) changes in the Episcopal Church

Meanwhile, over the past few years, we have seen minor changes in the Episcopal Church, both in policy and in practice.

These include:

Incoming presiding bishop Sean Rowe, unlike his predecessors, no longer recuses himself from his role under the Title IV clergy disciplinary canons.

Minor changes also have been made around Title IV and the way it is implemented, including:

  • Creating a dedicated intake officer for Title IV complaints against bishops, with mixed success and marginal improvements in the process.
  • Finally setting up a mechanism for the pastoral response mandated under Title IV. This requirement has, until now, been ignored by the national church.
  • Removing Todd Ousley, the previous head of the Office of Pastoral Development, from his role in training bishops. Ousley, who consistently refused to enforce Title IV via claims he could set up his own, alternative pastoral process, left behind a backlog of Title IV cases that he had largely ignored. This, even as he ensured that other bishops accused of misconduct received golden parachutes, while ignoring the pastoral needs of abuse victims.
  • Clarifying via amendment to Title IV that all cases must end with a pastoral response, versus outright dismissal. That said, the lack of a definition means that many judicatories still treat a “pastoral response” as being nothing more than muttering nice words to the complainant.
  • Creating a “restorative covenant” for cases that may not rise to the level of a full Title IV case. That said, intake officers remain trigger-happy when it comes to dismissing Title IV cases, ignoring the canonical mandates that they not attempt to investigate Title IV claims, or assess the accuracy or evidentiary weight of information in a complaint.
  • Clarifying via amendment of Title IV the limited role of the intake officer in proceedings. That said, because most intake officers in our experience don’t bother to read Title IV, this has made very little difference.
  • Implementing a 15-month timeline for completion of the Title IV process. To be clear, we see no sign of any improvements due to this change, with just the intake phase of Title IV cases sometimes taking months, even in Sean Rowe’s office.

So what lessons can TEC learn from the Makin Report?

Lack of HR function

One of the biggest problems with the church’s Title IV canon is that it often serves as an alternative to human resources (HR) processes.

In the Roman church, disciplinary processes are reserved for true canonical violations, like heresy or failure to obey directions from the Vatican. Other issues, like abuse or embezzlement, are treated, at least initially, as HR issues.

The result in the Roman Church is largely positive. Thus, allegations of church policies, including bullying, involving a church employee are dealt with not by a bishop, but instead by HR professionals. As a result, outcomes are often swift and certain.

On the other hand, sexual misconduct is handled by independent professionals, with outcomes audited by independent outsiders. Thus, the whole, “I know Fr. Scoundrel and he’s a good man” routine, far too common in TEC, is avoided.

To be clear, we recognize that the unique hybrid polity of TEC, which involves aspects of congregational and hierarchical governance, makes this approach challenging.

That said, there is nothing to stop dioceses from essentially forming de facto archdioceses, and sharing professional HR, audit, and other resources. And while bishops often fiercely guard their prerogatives, this approach gets them out of the hot seat when it comes to transactional HR matters.

Inadequate enforcement of Title IV among intake officers and judicatories

Another huge issue from our vantage point is that bishops and intake officers alike feel free to ignore the requirements of Title IV, while doing so with impunity.

Part of the issue is that many, de facto, don’t recognize that the focus of Title IV has changed. In the past, it was a win/lose procedure, in which a respondent was either guilty or not guilty. Now, the process is supposed to focus on healing, justice, reconciliation, and accountability.

The failure to recognize this change causes many to remain reluctant to implement what they see as the “nuclear option” of Title IV. But healing and reconciliation should be at the core of what it is to be a church. Thus, from our perspective, dismissal of Title IV complaints should be rare indeed.

Moreover, we still routinely see intake officers undertake unauthorized investigations, make conclusions as to the adequacy of evidence, and otherwise act corruptly. When this happens, there is next to no recourse for the complainant.

To be clear, an intake officer (or bishop) who sandbags a Title IV complaint must be held accountable if church members are to trust the church or its processes.

Tension between a desire by bishops to retain control of Title IV and their desire to avoid accountability

Anyone who doubts that the Episcopal Church is organizationally narcissistic need look only to this issue to dispel doubts.

On the one hand, time and again bishops have resisted calls for a national intake officer. Such a person could bring much-needed professionalism and independence to the role.

On the other hand, when Title IV is mishandled, as is far too often the case, bishops diocesan want to be able to shrug their shoulders and say, “Well, we did our best.”

But that doesn’t cut it.

When a Title IV complaint is filed, the complainant often already is facing trauma and feelings of betrayal. And when a complaint goes south, which is more the norm than the exception, the ensuing emotional and spiritual harm often is irreparable and worse than the original injury.

Thus, the Title IV process must be professionalized and rendered independent of diocesan authorities. If nothing else, the dismal outcomes we see coming from the current arrangement are helping neither bishops, nor complainants, nor the church itself.

Inadequate whistleblower protections

While the recent adoption of whistleblower protections in Title IV is a welcome change, it’s too little, too late. Moreover, it works about as well as Title IV does as a whole, which is to say, barely, if at all.

In our experience, complainants almost invariably experience retaliation, both from diocesan officials and local clergy.

Doubt it?

Consider the situation in the Diocese of New York, in which clergy at St Thomas Church Fifth Avenue responded to allegations of sexual assault by barring the complainant from the church. Subsequently, both the church and the diocese sent defamatory per se statements throughout the parish and the diocese, falsely accusing the victim of being a “domestic terrorist” and having been arrested for making terroristic threats.

To reiterate: These allegations are fabrications.

Similar outcomes pertained in a recent case in Cazenovia, New York, in which attorneys for the Diocese improperly barred a parishioner from her own parish in a decidedly un-Christian move.

Relatedly, there is a similar situation in the Episcopal Diocese of San Diego involving Bishop Susan Brown Snook’s seemingly bollixed response to allegations of sexual harassment.

Refusal to hold parish-level clergy accountable

In addition to the church’s refusal to hold intake officers and bishops accountable for refusing to meet their obligations under Title IV, there’s profound reluctance to hold parish-level clergy responsible for their misconduct.

For example, Bishop Paula Clark and the Episcopal Diocese of Chicago refuse to hold perjuring priest Will Bouvel accountable for courtroom lies he told about a parishioner. (Indeed, the Diocese continues to defend Bouvel.)

And, of course, even a quick trip through this publication makes clear that there are numerous similar situations across the church, including alleged child rapist Richard Losch, who appears poised to die a priest despite strong evidence that he did, in fact, rape a boy in the 1970s.

So why does the Episcopal Church do this?

Often, the excuse judicatories offer is that they don’t want to cause parishioners additional trauma.

Other times, it’s some vague reference to the passage of time, or “I wasn’t there when it happened.”

But the reality typically is that bishops simply want to protect the church’s reputation, even if that means causing harm to members.

Lack of independence

We touched on this earlier, but it bears further discussion.

Specifically, Title IV often is little more than poorly done performative art, due to the fact that intake officers and bishops often have an existing relationship with a clergy respondent.

In addition, bishops, who serve on the Title IV reference panel, have by definition a pastoral relationship with priests in their dioceses.

This situation is exacerbated by the role of intake officers, who also serve on Title IV reference panels. If they dismiss a complaint at intake and their decision is overturned on appeal, they essentially wind up with responsibility for a case that they’ve already tried once to shut down.

Needless to say, that creates a powerful bias against taking the complaint seriously going forward, and bishops are highly unlikely in our experience to disagree with an intake officer. So, appealing a Title IV dismissal at intake is almost always a waste of time.

Relatedly, there is no appeal by the complainant from an adverse reference panel decision, no matter how outrageous the outcome.

For these reasons, the only real solution is to remove Title IV entirely from church officials, and set it up as an independent process run by an outside law firm or non-profit. But given dynamics in the House of Bishops, we see little chance this will ever happen.

Limited definition of abuse

Another huge issue for the denomination is that it remains mired in a Mad Men-era time warp in which the only things that count for purposes of clergy discipline are sex, drugs, and sometimes money. Even then, things are hit-or-miss.

Meanwhile, as the Makin Report indicates, spiritual abuse remains alive and well in the Anglican Communion.

And, to be clear, while Anglican Watch has had some role in most recent Title IV cases, we have yet to see a case in which spiritual abuse was even on the judicatory’s radar, let alone actionable.

Indeed, most bishops just give a blank look when someone discusses spiritual abuse, or they say, “Well, tell the vestry about it,” as if that will actually accomplish something.

As for bullying, harassment, and similar misconduct, forget it. There is no fact pattern in which an intake officer or bishop will treat these issues as actionable.

Lack of audits

The church’s model policies talk about self-audits, but we have yet to see a church or other Episcopal entity conduct a meaningful audit. Yes, some, like St. Thomas Church Fifth Avenue, will have an outside entity conduct an “audit” as one component of impression management, but that is not the same as conducting annual independent audits, as the Roman Church does.

Why is this important?

The answer is simple: If Sean Rowe and others who claim to take Title IV seriously were to survey church members to collect data on Title IV and outcomes, they would be shocked to discover how widespread the problems are, and how bad the outcomes.

Further, as the Makin Report discusses, the church has, in our experience, zero empathy for victims of abuse.

Indeed, many of the people we have worked with since Anglican Watch was founded in 2015 have found ELCA and Catholic clergy to be far more supportive of victims, and willing both to believe victims and to provide pastoral care. (Recall that, in the Losch case, even appeals from an ELCA bishop and its legal department were ignored by corrupt Episcopal clergy, including feckless retired bishop Alan Gates and spectacularly indifferent former presiding bishop Michael Curry.)

What next?

As the COE implements the recommendations of the Makin Report, it is essential that TEC stop with the magical thinking that somehow it is good at preventing and addressing abuse. The reality is it is good at neither, and it is paying a terrible price for its narcissistic self-deception.

That price includes a largely unrecognized loss of members, lasting reputational harm, and discredit to the denomination’s claim to be “loving, liberating, lifegiving.”

Leave a comment