The Church of England’s independent safeguarding auditors have identified an old problem: the people doing the work are making progress, while some of the people running the institution are getting in the way.
In its 2025 annual report, published in July 2026, INEQE Safeguarding Group documents measurable improvements across dioceses and cathedrals. INEQE is an independent safeguarding consultancy led by Jim Gamble, a former senior police officer and founding head of the UK’s Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre. The Archbishops’ Council appointed the firm in 2023 to audit every Church of England diocese and cathedral against the church’s National Safeguarding Standards and to publish its findings.
But it also warns that resistance from influential senior officials, coupled with uncertainty over the future of safeguarding oversight, threatens to undermine those gains.
In other words, the Church of England has made progress despite some of its leadership, not necessarily because of it.
For Episcopalians familiar with the failures of Title IV, the findings should sound painfully familiar.
Progress on the ground, resistance at the top
INEQE’s second year of audits involved 10,348 contributors, including 9,153 anonymous survey responses and more than 500 direct engagement sessions. Victim and survivor participation increased 38 percent, while the program recorded 21,352 engagements across its first two years.
Those numbers matter. They suggest that people throughout the church are increasingly willing to discuss safeguarding failures and participate in efforts to correct them.
The auditors also identified improvements in safer recruitment, confidence in reporting concerns, and safeguarding for cathedral choristers. In particular, the report describes a shift away from practices that put musical excellence ahead of children’s welfare.
But the encouraging findings come with an important qualification.
According to INEQE, significant resistance comes not generally from senior clergy but from a small number of influential diocesan officers and individuals within the national church.
In his foreword, Gamble describes officials willing to “hide behind exceptionalism, Canon Law, tradition, and procedural defensiveness” rather than embrace operationally independent safeguarding arrangements.
The report specifically identifies resistance surrounding the Director of Safeguarding role, intended to strengthen the independence of safeguarding operations.
The problem is not that everyone opposes reform. A relatively small number of influential people can frustrate changes supported by many others.
And apparently, bureaucracy remains one of the church’s most reliable spiritual gifts.
When in doubt, commission another review
The auditors also describe a time-honored form of institutional obstruction: waiting for the next report.
Previously, some church bodies deferred implementing recommendations while awaiting the Future of Church Safeguarding report. Now, according to INEQE, the reason for delay is the Safeguarding Structures Programme.
Different program, same problem.
INEQE warns that ignoring evidence-based recommendations creates risk. The implication is straightforward: safeguarding improvements should not remain on hold indefinitely while church officials debate organizational structures.
A separate audit of the National Safeguarding Team, published in May, also recommended specialist human resources capacity to distinguish employment and conduct matters from safeguarding responsibilities.
That distinction matters. Safeguarding processes should not replace ordinary personnel management, nor should employment procedures obscure genuine safeguarding concerns.
Neither problem is solved by creating another committee.
How the church got here
The latest findings follow years of safeguarding scandals that have shaken the Church of England’s leadership.
The Makin Review into serial abuser John Smyth helped precipitate Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby’s resignation in November 2024. The report exposed serious institutional failures in responding to allegations of abuse.
At General Synod in February 2025, safeguarding dominated the agenda. Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell faced a procedural challenge reflecting concerns about his own safeguarding record. Although the challenge failed, 73 members supported it and 43 abstained.
Synod then considered competing models for independent safeguarding.
One would transfer national safeguarding functions to an independent body. A more comprehensive alternative would also transfer diocesan and cathedral safeguarding staff.
Instead, Synod endorsed the more limited approach in the short term, while calling for further work on the legal and practical requirements of the fuller model.
The compromise left substantial safeguarding responsibilities within existing diocesan and cathedral structures.
Survivors and advocates were unimpressed. Critics argued that Synod effectively preserved bishops’ existing power.
That decision provides important context for INEQE’s latest findings. The church has acknowledged the need for independent safeguarding while continuing to debate how much independence it is prepared to surrender.
And now its auditors are documenting resistance to implementing change.
Scandals continue while reform inches forward
The intervening months have brought further controversy.
The Charity Commission criticized safeguarding governance involving the dioceses of Liverpool and Chelmsford following allegations against former Liverpool bishop John Perumbalath, who has denied wrongdoing.
Meanwhile, Bishop of Lincoln Stephen Conway was suspended following his February 2026 arrest on suspicion of sexual assault. He subsequently resigned, effective October 1.
The prompt suspension deserves acknowledgment. An arrest, however, is not a conviction, and the allegations should not be treated as facts.
The larger question is whether the Church of England has developed safeguarding arrangements capable of responding consistently, independently and transparently, regardless of the seniority of those involved.
In November 2025, the church’s lead safeguarding bishops issued an update marking the first anniversary of the Makin Review, outlining continued work toward independent scrutiny and accountability.
INEQE’s findings demonstrate why the distinction between promising reform and delivering it remains important.
Sound familiar, Episcopalians?
Now substitute a few terms.
In England, officials invoke canon law, institutional tradition and exceptionalism. In the Episcopal Church, similar arguments can surface as appeals to diocesan autonomy, ecclesiastical polity, pastoral discretion and Title IV procedures.
Different vocabulary, same institutional instincts.
The Episcopal Church has its own record of disciplinary failures involving bishops. Its handling of complaints against former Florida bishop John Howard, for example, ended in October 2025 through an accord without a contested hearing or admission of wrongdoing.
And as Anglican Watch has repeatedly documented, the church’s Title IV system has suffered from inconsistent intake decisions, inadequate transparency and a troubling tendency to substitute informal pastoral responses for meaningful accountability.
The Episcopal Church has undertaken disciplinary reviews and faced external scrutiny. What it has not established is a comparable, comprehensive program of independent safeguarding audits across every diocese, with publicly available findings and recommendations.
That distinction matters. Without systematic outside review, it becomes considerably harder to determine whether reported failures are isolated mistakes or symptoms of deeper institutional problems.
Indeed, the churchwide Title IV pilot included in Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe’s strategic plan, adopted by Executive Council on October 19, reflects an acknowledgment that existing diocesan arrangements need improvement. Centralizing expertise may help, but a church-administered disciplinary process is not the same thing as independent oversight.
And without independence, reform remains vulnerable to the very officials whose decisions may need examination.
What meaningful reform requires
INEQE’s findings point toward several practical requirements:
- Safeguarding leadership with genuine operational independence.
- Prompt implementation of evidence-based recommendations, rather than indefinite delays pending further reviews.
- Appropriate separation of human resources and safeguarding responsibilities.
- Meaningful participation by survivors in developing and evaluating safeguarding arrangements.
- Transparent accountability when officials resist or delay necessary reforms.
When recommendations are delayed, church members should know who is responsible, why implementation has stalled, and what risks remain unresolved.
The Church of England deserves credit for permitting outside auditors to examine its safeguarding arrangements and publish uncomfortable findings. That willingness to expose institutional weaknesses is itself a meaningful step toward accountability.
But an audit is not reform. Neither is a committee, a strategic plan or another reassuring statement from senior leadership.
Reform happens when recommendations are implemented, officials are held accountable, and survivors can report misconduct without having to navigate an institution more interested in protecting itself than protecting people.
INEQE has documented both encouraging progress and the forces threatening to derail it. The question now is whether the Church of England will confront those forces or continue allowing a handful of influential officials to obstruct change.
Until then, institutional drift remains an apt description.
And for the Episcopal Church, which has yet to undertake comparable nationwide independent scrutiny, the lesson is uncomfortable: if safeguarding reform can be obstructed even with outside auditors watching, imagine how much easier obstruction becomes when no one is looking.
Sources
- INEQE Safeguarding Group: 2025 independent safeguarding audit annual report
- Church Times: Safeguarding progress resisted at high level
- Church of England: Independent audit of the National Safeguarding Team
- The Living Church: General Synod votes on safeguarding independence
- International Business Times: Bishop of Lincoln resigns amid investigation
- Episcopal News Service: Church of England provides safeguarding update after Makin Review
- Episcopal News Service: Disciplinary cases against former Bishop John Howard conclude
- Episcopal News Service: Executive Council backs presiding bishop’s strategic vision, including Title IV pilot





