Episcopal priest Ed Monk’s efforts to blame parishioners for his alleged theft underscore the importance of a lengthy prison sentence at criminal trial

In recent oral arguments before the Episcopal Church’s Title IV Court of Review, attorneys for Corsicana, Tex., priest Ed Monk blamed parishioners for his alleged theft of church funds, arguing that the issue was really one of “sloppy governance, sloppy bookkeeping.” Additionally, attorneys for Monk objected to various purported procedural errors, including a claimed lack of specificity in the Title IV “statement of offense.” Monk’s attorney also claims he did not have ample opportunity to defend himself at the hearing panel level.

As we have said previously, we believe Monk’s claims are spurious and underscore a lack of remorse that warrants imposition of the maximum possible criminal sentence when the matter goes to trial in 2026 and he presumably is found guilty.

 Role of Court of Review

To begin with, let’s look at the authority of the Court of Review, which hears appeals from diocesan Title IV hearing panels.

Under the canons, a Title IV hearing panel has authority over procedural and substantive issues, including assessing the credibility and weight of evidence offered during proceedings. As such, the Court of Review cannot substitute its opinion for that of the hearing panel, and can only overturn the latter’s decision if it finds that the hearing panel erred. Moreover, the canons expressly prohibit overturning a decision for procedural error when the error was not prejudicial to the respondent.

 Relatedly, because Title IV proceedings are neither criminal nor civil in nature, but rather ecclesiastical, the canons expressly forbid respondents from raising constitutional guarantees.

The point about constitutional guarantees is significant in the Monk case, because much of his argument at the hearing panel level revolved around assertions that the Title IV proceedings somehow prejudiced Monk’s constitutional rights in future criminal proceedings. That argument is clearly a red herring, since the only issue in the Title IV proceedings is whether Monk can remain a priest.

That, in turn, brings us to Monk’s newfound claims that the hearing panel denied him the opportunity to explain how his alleged theft of hundreds of thousands of dollars was actually the fault of his church’s lay leadership.

Specifically, Monk declined the opportunity to explain his actions during the diocesan investigation, subsequently claiming that the Title IV proceedings prejudiced his pending criminal trial. 

That, of course, begs the question: If Monk had a reasonable explanation of his conduct, why would he not have embraced the opportunity to share this information with the hearing panel?

Indeed, Monk’s objections to the Title IV hearing panel proceedings make clear that he feared any evidence that emerged during the Title IV process would be adverse to him. Thus, it is shocking and appalling that Monk now tries to claim he didn’t get a chance to proffer an explanation for his conduct.

About that credit card…

We also need only look to the allegations that Monk opened a credit card using the church treasurer’s Social Security number to address Monk’s arguments.

Specifically, the church treasurer is a 90-year-old retired physician. Thus, assuming the allegations are accurate, Monk’s behavior would not only constitute identity theft but also constitute elder abuse.

In this context, Monk’s attorney is trying to tell us that the issue is bad governance and bookkeeping. Let’s consider how that conversation might play out:

Vestry: You need our approval to open credit cards.

Monk: Not in this case. It wasn’t a church credit card.

Vestry: Whose credit card is it?

Monk: It’s mine.

Vestry: And what is the name on the credit card?

Monk: It’s in the name of our treasurer.

Vestry: Did he give you permission to open a credit card?

Monk: No, but I’m the rector.

Vestry: That’s not good enough.

Monk: Oh, no one told me.

In other words, any claim that Monk didn’t know what he was doing is laughable.

And if he doesn’t already know that using other people’s Social Security numbers to open credit cards is identity theft, all the more reason to defrock him.

Tangential issues

Next, we turn to the slime pit of other issues in this matter, many of which underscore how badly run the Episcopal Church often is.

Specifics:

  1. The fact that Monk allegedly stole hundreds of thousands of dollars from his parish reinforces the need for all parishes to undertake an annual financial audit. Yes, doing so is expensive, but it’s far cheaper than the sort of losses facing the parish, many of which insurance will not reimburse. And for the umpteenth time, an Agreed-Upon Procedures (AUP) is not an audit and has no attestation value. That said, a breakdown in internal controls is never a legitimate basis for theft.
  2. Monk’s approximately 20-year tenure is a common factor in many of the embezzlement cases we see. Indeed, we increasingly question whether Episcopal clergy should be able to stay in one position for more than 7-10 years. Beyond that, even a skilled priest rarely has the gifts needed to help a church grow and prosper—and far too often, priests who stay beyond that come to regard the church as “theirs,” rather than a faith community they serve. In other words, extended stays exacerbate the worst aspects of narcissism and clericalism that we see among Episcopal clergy.
  3. Monk’s claim that the Title IV “Statement of Offense” was inadequate is nonsense. He clearly understood the charges against him at all relevant times and did not raise any objections at the hearing panel level. Indeed, we again note that Monk objected to the hearing panel proceedings on the very ground that they might later influence his future criminal trial. So it’s not like he was left scratching his head, wondering if, for example, the issue was one of alleged heresy versus embezzlement. And, to be clear, that is the purpose of discovery at the hearing panel level — to flesh out the specifics of the allegations, claims, and defenses in a case.
  4. Monk’s argument that somehow donors might have been willing to bolster his arguably meager salary is bull. Not only are we confident that he did not declare any of this income for tax purposes, but taking compensation on the side directly from parishioners is, in itself, a grave ethical violation. The only compensation he was entitled to was what was approved by the vestry. Thus, Monk’s attorney has, de facto, just argued in the alternative that, in fact, the diocese should defrock Monk.
  5. As the Court of Review panel noted, we are troubled by the mediocre quality of the hearing panel transcript. That said, Monk provides no evidence that this prejudiced him at the hearing panel level. Thus, this is less about the validity of the hearing panel’s decision and more about the dignity of the Title IV process. In other words, we’d like to see the Diocese of Dallas take things seriously.
  6. Speaking of the Diocese of Dallas and its handling of Title IV, we note that George Sumner, acting in collusion with diocesan chancellor Cory Floyd, sandbagged a Title IV complaint against Texarkana priest David JA Halt for his role in retaliating against a priest who opposed sexual harassment related to the St. James parish. (Floyd, for the record, is a member of St. James.) Thus, it’s difficult to criticize sloppy governance at the parish level when the bishop diocesan and the chancellor engage in unethical conduct. We also note that Floyd has no legitimate role in the Title IV intake process per the canons.

Bottom line

The more we see of Monk, his conduct in the Title IV process, and the comments from his brother on this site, the more we are convinced of several things:

  • Monk is both guilty and unrepentant. Thus, he deserves the maximum criminal penalty when his case goes to trial.
  • Monk’s lawyer’s own arguments underscore the possibility that his wife and family were aware of his alleged embezzlement, since he stated during the hearing that Monk’s income was “relatively humble.” That begs the question: If those involved recognized that Monk’s income was relatively meager, where did he get the funds for his travel and spending? How could his wife and his older brother not be aware that Monk was living above his obvious means? And to be clear, St. John’s average pledge and plate is only a little north of $200,000 annually, so it’s not like there was tons of money lying loose along the margins or lavish expense accounts. Thus, we encourage local law enforcement to investigate the possibility that other members of Monk’s family were also part of his criminal endeavors.

    St John’s Corsicana
    St John’s Corsicana
  • We hope the parish and the Diocese will consider filing a civil lawsuit against Monk and any other parties involved in his illegal conduct.
  • George Sumner is a sleazebag of the worst sort.

As things stand, we have zero respect for Monk or his family.

3 thoughts on “Episcopal priest Ed Monk’s efforts to blame parishioners for his alleged theft underscore the importance of a lengthy prison sentence at criminal trial”

  1. Having watched the hearing, I have a very different take. I feel you’re exaggerating the issues here for click bait. The real issue was a lack of fair hearing from the diocese. The board of review was very focused on that. I believe there are much deeper issues and vendettas in play here.

    Reply
    • First, we do not instantly approve all comments. Believe it or not, the AW volunteers have lives outside the publication. So don’t get your panties in a knot.

      Second, let’s go right to the heart to the matter: It was acceptable for Monk to allegedly open a fraudulent credit card on what basis? Or steal hundreds of thousands of dollars from the parish?

      Sorry, unless you can show that Monk is not an embezzler, there is NO fact pattern under which it was not appropriate to recommend that he be defrocked. And yes, we watched the entire sordid hearing.

      As things stand, you are reinforcing our conclusion that the criminal court judge needs to throw the book at Monk. Because so far, we see zero evidence of accountability, which speaks to that whole “honest and honorable” thing of yours.

      Moreover, given the extent to which you and Monk’s family members are trying to run interference for him, we recommend that law enforcement expand its investigation to include Monk’s wife and brother. The notion they had no clue about his allegedly criminal conduct is laughable, at best.

      Reply

Leave a comment