In a ruling issued last week, the Episcopal Court of Review overturned a hearing panel decision that recommended that Dallas priest Ed Monk, now facing felony criminal charges after allegedly embezzling more than $300,000 from his parish, be defrocked as an Episcopal priest.
Among the Court’s concerns were:
- The failure to allow Monk’s attorney to participate in the hearing fully.
- The dismal quality of the hearing transcript, which contained numerous sections marked as inaudible.
- The failure to swear witnesses in under oath as required by canon.
- The improper use of the criminal prosecutor to present selective grand jury information from an undisclosed expert forensic accounting report that was not provided to Monk or his counsel in advance of the hearing.
The opinion, which was not unanimous, requires that the matter return to the hearing panel for reconsideration.
Four Court of Review members — Delbert C. Glover, the Rev. Giovan Venable King, the Rt. Rev. E. Mark Stevenson and the Rev. Marisa Tabizon Thompson — dissented, saying that they did not find clear evidence that the Hearing Panel made a mistake in finding Monk guilty. Thus, they would have allowed the decision to stand.
Our take on things
Let’s start at the top in this matter.
Even a cursory review of the evidence in question leaves zero doubt in our mind that Monk is guilty of all charges. Moreover, he never really tries to argue otherwise — at this point, he’s fighting a rearguard action in which he’s throwing random junk against the wall, while hoping something sticks.
Making matters worse is that Monk shows no remorse, and his family members have shown up on this forum and elsewhere, bemoaning the fact that he will, horror of horrors, be held accountable for his actions. Thus, we believe Monk deserves not only to be defrocked, but to face the longest possible criminal sentence when the felony criminal trial concludes.
We’d also add that Monk’s outsized lifestyle, together with the interference his family is running for him, suggests to us that the criminal conduct in question may well go beyond Monk himself. As in, we think it’s time to conduct a criminal investigation of Monk’s wife and his brother.
In other words, we’d gladly see Monk tossed into prison for the rest of his life.
That said, while we have mixed feelings, we support the Court of Review majority decision.
Why?
Simply put, we do so because far too many Title IV cases are Charlie Foxtrots of the worst possible sort. The Episcopal Church, which even today sits on vast wealth, far too often treats hearing panel proceedings as poorly done, free-wheeling meetings, crap-slapped together at the eleventh hour by some low-level diocesan official, and in which anything goes.
Such an approach undermines the very core of the church, namely its claim to moral authority. Indeed, any denomination that cannot ensure its clergy act with integrity faces an imminent existential threat. And on this score, the Episcopal Church is little more than a flashback to the Roman church of the 1950s — deny, evade, avoid, equivocate, litigate, repeat as needed.
Indeed, one of the worst offenders is Monk’s own diocese, in which the bishop plays fast and loose with the Title IV canons, personally participates in cover-up and sexual harassment/retaliation, and more. And that clown of an intake officer for bishops, Barb Kempf, will find any possible excuse to avoid dealing with these issues, which only adds to the mess.
So, where does that leave us?
As things stand, the feckless behavior of the Diocese of Dallas means we’ll have to slog through this process yet again, replete with Monk’s childish and noisy machinations and his ludicrous claims that somehow, magically, the church is violating his constitutional rights.
At the same time, we are hopeful that this reversal sends a clear message to diocesan judicatories: Stop with the fun and games.
Indeed, the notion that respondents have discovery access to the evidence presented against them at trial (think the grand jury reports) is a foundational concept of American jurisprudence. The notion that it’s okay to proceed without this is nothing short of shocking, especially at a time when the executive branch of the US government increasingly seeks to rule by fiat.
Still, we need to be a bit nuanced here.
For example, while Monk’s attorney may indeed have been unwell at the time of the hearing, the overall level of dilatory behavior on Monk’s part makes it easy to understand why the Hearing Panel may not have been terribly sympathetic to his requests for delay.
Plus, to be clear: Most attorneys have a plan B in place in case something prevents them from attending a proceeding. That plan may be a trusted colleague or peer who steps in, written pleadings adequate to cover all the points they want to raise, or even just contacting defense counsel 48 hours out to move for a continuance jointly.
We further note that Monk doesn’t even attempt to refute the most egregious charges against him, including identity theft.
In other words, given what we’ve seen from Monk so far, we’re more than a little dubious about any claim he makes, including those made via defense counsel.


