Update: Diocese of Virginia amends Title IV complaint against priest Cayce Ramey

The Episcopal Diocese of Virginia recently released an updated statement of alleged offenses against Episcopal priest Cayce Ramey, reflecting additional potential misconduct. Ramey briefly gained notoriety after refusing to participate in Holy Communion to object, he claimed, to the denomination’s refusal to repent for its role in slavery.

Among the additional charges against Ramey are allegations that he:

  1. Refused to cooperate in the original Title IV proceedings against him, including by engaging in witness tampering and by failing to provide discovery as required by the Title IV hearing panel.
  2. Failed to abide by the restrictions on ministry imposed upon him by Bishop Diocesan Mark Stevenson, including by appearing at General Convention dressed in clericals and holding himself forth as an Episcopal priest.
  3. Failed to obey Stevenson’s direction to meet with him quarterly to discuss the case.

Thus, Ramey is accused, inter alia, of failing to obey his bishop and conduct unbecoming.

Our reaction

As we’ve previously reported, this is a knotty situation, but one in which we support the Diocese of Virginia and its efforts to defrock Ramey. That said, we have some concerns about the situation.

On the one hand, the Diocese appears to have played right into Ramey’s hands. Specifically, Ramey clearly wants to transition out of priestly ministry, and he’s trying to credential himself with outrageous and deceitful claims that he’s being tried for being a “heretic.”

To be clear, no one has accused him of being a heretic. We’ve accused him of being a liar and a jackass, and we suspect he has a mental illness, based on comments from former Ecclesiastical Authority Susan Goff. Meanwhile, the Diocese accuses him of conduct unbecoming and more. But no one says he’s a heretic.

We also have mixed feelings about the claim that Ramey is required to participate in Mass. We know lots of clergy who haven’t said Mass in years, and there’s no canonical provision that requires it. That said, the Diocese finally came around and issued a pastoral direction telling Ramey he has to take communion, so that matter is now off the table. But to be clear: Susan Goff’s thing about “I don’t know how you can be a priest and not take Communion,” was clearly not binding.

We also disagree with two aspects of the Court of Review’s decision, which overturned the previous decision to defrock Ramey. Specifically:

  1. The Court of Review made much of the need to seek healing and reconciliation, thus implying that the Diocese did not do so. To be clear: While we are often harshly critical of the Diocese of Virginia, it has been more than patient with Ramey in this matter. Indeed, had anyone at this publication been bishop, we would have metaphorically tied Ramey to a tree and shot him a long time ago. In other words, if anything, the Diocese has been far too patient with this knucklehead.
  2. Procedurally, we see no support in the canons for the Court of Review’s claim that Ramey’s misconduct during the original Title IV proceedings had to be addressed via new complaints. Indeed, the canons vest the Hearing Panel with considerable latitude to maintain the integrity of the process, including the ability to impose sanctions for dilatory behavior. Thus, we urge the Court of Review to refrain in future cases from substituting its judgment for the provisions of the canons, or from second-guessing the procedural decisions of the hearing panel.

At the same time, we question the wisdom of the Diocesan decision to go hammer and tongs after Ramey. The guy is manipulative, dishonest, and indifferent to his parishioners’ needs, and no one is going to hire him. Moreover, while the Diocese is dumping all kinds of time and energy into this mess, we’ve seen it do relatively little in far more serious cases of clergy misconduct. Thus, given all that needs to happen in the Diocese, this may not be the best way to allocate resources.

That said, we are mindful that Ramey is a train wreck in slow motion. And if there is one thing we continue to urge the episcopacy to do, it’s to clean up ethics in the denomination. So, at the end of the day, we entirely support the Diocese in giving Ramey the heave-ho.

Relatedly, Ramey really is a piece of work. Even the bit in the updated statement of offenses about how he ghosted Bishop Stevenson for his quarterly meeting is just childish, stupid, and rude. If nothing else, given that most bishops won’t give you the time of day, it’s laudable that Stevenson would take the time to meet with this dolt. And if he really plans not to attend, having the courtesy to pick up the phone and say, “I won’t be there,” isn’t too much to ask.

Meanwhile, in Ramey’s pleadings, he spends a lot of time trying to impress us with his bit about having been a Marine and his “battlefield promotions.” Still, any military officer knows and respects the chain of command and obeys lawful orders from their superior officers.

So, Ramey can get the hell out of Dodge and quit with the BS games. He has no business being a priest.

A copy of the updated allegations follows.

Disclosure: Anglican Watch editor Eric Bonetti, a former member of the Diocese of Virginia, remains on medical leave and had no role in the development of this article.

Leave a comment