Just when things couldn’t get any worse for Trinity Upperville, its wardens, both of whom need to resign, are pulling the “loose lips sink ships” routine in an effort to silence criticism, having just sent a vaguely threatening cease-and-desist letter to the members of the congregation. The move is both remarkably stupid and evinces a profound lack of understanding of the role of transparency and accountability in any healthy church.
In their letter, the wardens, who seem determined to run interference for alleged pedophile and outgoing rector Jonathan “Johnny Boy” Adams, allude to vague but allegedly serious “security threats,” even as they proclaim, “We share [this warning] because the dire consequences of continued escalation must be understood.”
They then go on to say that security will be at the church, both during services and during weekly operations.
The consistent theme in the wardens’ missive is not, however, security but rather the limitation of information sharing, both within the parish and among outside audiences.
The letter raises several issues:
- If the wardens think that their efforts will, in any way, reduce coverage of the debacle now underway in the parish, they are profoundly misinformed. In fact, two additional outlets now are preparing stories, and one of the largest dailies in the US is asking hard questions.
- Both wardens evince a lack of understanding of human nature. Not only do church members not want to live in a command-and-control environment, but the fastest way to push information to a media outlet is to tell people not to.
- If the wardens think they can intimidate this media outlet (or any other) with vague claims of security threats, they are very much mistaken. Our priority is to protect children and parishioners, and to bring light to the darkness.
- The wardens’ letter underscores the importance of the diocese providing adult supervision. The latter was a huge misstep by the wardens and only reinforces the conclusion that they are trying to cover up the current debacle.
- Most importantly, we see nowhere near this level of energy when it comes to protecting a boy and his family, which makes the current situation even more appalling.
Anglican Watch condemns the wardens’ efforts to engage in cover-up. We have zero tolerance for any effort, direct or indirect, to aid or abet an alleged pedophile. And we challenge the wardens to provide any credible evidence of a security threat. Or explain the “dire consequences” that they are threatening.
We’ll wait.
A copy of the wardens’ letter follows:






The real security risk: Johnny Boy.
By the way, I know Scott Andrews. Let’s just say he’s an improbable choice for senior warden.
Does the phrase, “Digging yourself in even deeper” come to mind?
Someone should tell these clowns to stop making things worse. As it is, in ten years the place will be standing empty, absent a 180-degree change of course.
As it stands, they’re paying severance to an alleged pedophile.
Maybe parishioners can do another rousing rendition of “For he’s a jolly good fellow,” just like they did when Johnny Boy returned to ministry, replete with his lies about being fully exonerated.
Just an idea.
For me, this situation was the last straw. My dad was a priest, I grew up in the church, I raised four kids in the church. The Diocese sounds just like Nancy Reagan and her dresses: “She made her own little rule and broke her own little rule.” No, a few rules are not an okay way to deal with the issues involving Johnny Boy Adams. He needed to go and not come back. The Diocese has lost any moral reference point it once had and clearly doesn’t understand abuse.
As far as the asshats at Trinity, they are a dangerous mixture of deluded, clueless, and spineless. No one I’d want in my life.
I asked my church to remove my name from the parish register and cancel my pledge.
I am no longer an Episcopalian.
TEC really has reached the end when a bishop thinks it’s okay to return someone like Johnny Boy to ministry.
I may try the Quakers, or maybe UUA. TEC has lost all moral reference points.
This is what happens when a church becomes a social club, versus a group of people who worship God. Pretty building (if you like this sort of precious stuff), but you won’t find Jesus anywhere on the premises, except in name only.