Title IV case involving Texas priest accused of embezzlement goes to Court of Review

The Title IV clergy disciplinary case against disgraced Episcopal priest Ed Monk, who is canonically resident in the Diocese of Dallas, has been appealed to the Court of Review. The diocesan-level Title IV hearing panel recommended that the bishop diocesan, George Sumner, defrock Monk.

Monk is criminally charged with three separate felony offenses, including allegedly stealing more than $300,000 from his parish, St. John’s, located in Corsicana, Texas.

Additionally, Monk allegedly fraudulently opened a credit card in the name of a parishioner, using the card to go on lavish spending sprees.

Monk’s objections

Monk’s case is one in which it appears he has been caught red-handed, while he and his attorneys try to respond to the charges by throwing spaghetti at the walls to see what, if anything, will stick.

The result is predictably ludicrous, and we feel sorry for defense counsel in this matter.

Among Monk’s claims:

  • That somehow the Episcopal Church violated his Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights by calling witnesses that may subsequently be called in his upcoming criminal trial. That’s laughable, since Title IV is neither criminal nor civil in nature, but rather ecclesiastical. Under the First Amendment, the Episcopal Church has the exclusive right to discipline its clergy. Moreover, the Fourth and Fifth Amendments do not apply to private individuals or entities.
  • That Nashotah House, the Anglo-Catholic seminary where Monk served on the board of directors, has already conducted its own financial audit and cleared Monk of any improprieties. That’s another laughable statement, since it is conclusory in nature, and we have neither seen the audit nor the audit report. Moreover, we doubt it was a forensic audit (if it exists at all), and audit reports don’t “clear” people of wrongdoing; they merely report that they found no irregularities, which is a far different matter.
  • There were procedural irregularities, including the naming of a parish warden as a complainant, despite the fact that she was never interviewed. Yet, the Title IV clergy disciplinary canons expressly state that someone may be named a complainant in a proceeding by the bishop, in order to afford them the same pastoral response as other complainants.

We also note that a background check of key players in the matter indicates that Monk is not the only bad apple; one individual, close to Monk, appears to have a felony criminal conviction in Texas for child indecency, as well as a so-called Chapter 20 bankruptcy, which is a Chapter 7 discharge accompanied by a Chapter 13 cramdown on the terms and conditions of debt.

Relatedly, we are confident that pastoral directions in the matter require that Monk not hold himself forth as an Episcopal priest, so we are puzzled as to why Joseph Monk, Ed’s son, refers to him as “Canon Monk” in his correspondence with us.

In our experience, large-scale alleged embezzlements of this nature rarely happen without a spouse’s knowledge. It simply is not possible to live this sort of lavish lifestyle on a priest’s salary without concluding something is seriously wrong.

Thus, we encourage law enforcement to consider whether Monk’s wife and children were potentially part of his corrupt activities.

Similarly, prosecutors should, we believe, consider Monk’s intransigence in the Title IV case as evincing a lack of contrition. Therefore, we strongly advocate for the imposition of the maximum possible criminal penalties for Monk and any other individuals involved in this matter.

Finally, the Monk case highlights the importance of churches and vestries taking their fiduciary obligations to the church seriously. That’s because a full recovery of the missing funds is highly unlikely at this point — even though Monk would be well-advised to start making restitution if he does not spend 20+ years in jail.

Thus, vestry members must:

  • See audit engagement letters and reports.
  • See all financial statements, including those for so-called separate ministries, like church schools, which often are actually legally part of the parish.
  • Refuse to fall for excuses from the rector about financial reports, like, “Well, I see them.” (Vestry members should see monthly financials, and with enough line-item detail to spot things like unauthorized salary increases for staff. Again, that must include all church programs—nothing should be “off budget” and beyond the review of vestry members.)
  • Be comfortable speaking out if something seems off.
  • Enjoy the protection of their bishop diocesan and other judicatories when they do speak out about possible problems.

As for Monk, we have zero patience for him and his antics. He is a priest in name only and has zero respect for this church or the people who make up the church. Nor is he taking responsibility for his actions.

While Monk is innocent until proven guilty, we believe him to be guilty, and that deserves the maximum possible criminal penalty.

2 thoughts on “Title IV case involving Texas priest accused of embezzlement goes to Court of Review”

  1. I wanted to take a moment to clear up a few misapprehensions of fact on your part:

    I am Joseph (Joe) Monk. I am Ed Monk’s older brother. The Joseph Monk you refer to in the article above is not Ed’s son, he is my firstborn son, and Ed’s nephew.

    Nobody in our family has a conviction for child indecency. A single click further on the Harris County District Clerk’s website would show you that the case was “no billed” by the Grand Jury (there was no probable cause that a crime had even been committed). The case was subsequently dismissed.

    Reply
    • Thank you for your comment. Interesting that you assume the issues with allegations of child indecency refer to someone in your family.

      As to the nonsense about “Canon” Monk’s alleged deprivation of his constitutional rights, we reiterate our position that these sort of ludicrous arguments underscore a seeming lack of contrition, thus warranting the maximum possible sentence. And assuming the allegations in question to be accurate, we find it improbable that Monk’s wife and other family were unaware that there were issues. Yes, Episcopal priests are often paid well, but the sort of spending alleged is facially inconsistent with clergy salaries.

      All involved would do well to focus on contrition and accountability. As things stand, we have even less respect for the Monk family than we did when the allegations first emerged.

      Reply

Leave a comment