Long before many churches publicly acknowledged their problems with sexual abuse, spiritual abuse, and institutional cover-ups, a small group of independent bloggers was documenting what church leaders preferred to keep quiet.
Among them were Dee Parsons, Julie Anne Smith, and Amy Smith, whose work helped establish an extraordinary community of independent religious-abuse watchdogs.
Their publications—The Wartburg Watch, Spiritual Sounding Board, and Watchkeep—are sister publications to Anglican Watch. Our editorial interests differ, but we share a conviction: churches don’t get a pass on misconduct merely because they claim to speak for God.
They have documented sexual abuse, spiritual abuse, authoritarianism, retaliation, and efforts to silence survivors. Their efforts show that a determined blogger can sometimes accomplish more than an entire ecclesiastical bureaucracy. That has not always endeared them to church leadership.
Bloggers, advocates, and unapologetic watchdogs
Dee Parsons does not consider herself a journalist. She identifies as a blogger, and we respect that distinction. Nor do our sister publications—or Anglican Watch—pretend to offer traditional, neutral, newspaper-style coverage. We are bloggers, researchers, advocates, and watchdogs with editorial perspectives. We make no apologies for them.
Having a point of view does not excuse getting the facts wrong. Documentary evidence, accurate attribution, distinguishing allegations from established facts, and correcting errors remain essential. But fairness does not require pretending that every institutional denial deserves the same weight as documented misconduct.
We are not here to provide religious institutions with flattering publicity. We’re here to examine the evidence, ask difficult questions, and advocate for accountability.
The Wartburg Watch: Holding religious authority accountable
The Wartburg Watch was founded in March 2009 by Darlene “Dee” Parsons and Wanda “Deb” Martin, following troubling experiences with religious leadership and its responses to abuse. The blog examined authoritarianism, Neo-Calvinism, complementarianism, and the misuse of religious authority before expanding its focus on sexual misconduct, spiritual abuse, domestic violence, and institutional cover-ups.
Martin eventually retired from blogging, while Parsons continued the work. A distinguishing strength of the site is its recognition that coercion, bullying, manipulation, and spiritual abuse can do lasting damage whether or not a crime has been committed.
We’ve previously covered threats to The Wartburg Watch’s online operations. The relationship is one we value greatly. For background, see the site’s history and mission and sixth-anniversary retrospective.
Apparently, some religious leaders find a blogger asking pointed questions more threatening than the conduct that prompted those questions.
Spiritual Sounding Board: The lawsuit that backfired
Spiritual Sounding Board grew from Julie Anne Smith’s experience criticizing her former Oregon church, Beaverton Grace Bible Church. In 2012, the church and its pastor brought a $500,000 defamation lawsuit against Smith and other former members. The case was dismissed. If the idea was to silence Smith, it backfired spectacularly.
Her blog became a resource for people confronting authoritarian pastors, spiritual abuse, patriarchy, sexual misconduct, and religious communities that retaliate against those who speak out. She also assembled extensive research, including a Ravi Zacharias research archive.
One of the site’s enduring contributions is helping survivors understand and recover from spiritual abuse, not merely naming misconduct. Her litigation archive is also recommended reading for church leaders contemplating lawsuits against their critics. Read it carefully.
Watchkeep: Following the evidence wherever it leads
Watchkeep reflects Amy Smith’s persistence in examining religious safeguarding failures. Smith began pressing for accountability after learning of allegations of child sexual abuse involving John Langworthy, a former youth minister at Prestonwood Baptist Church and a man once close to her family. Langworthy later pleaded guilty to child sexual abuse offenses in Mississippi.
Smith’s first-person account details her decision to act and the personal price she paid. She continued pursuing child protection and institutional accountability across religious groups, schools, and youth organizations.
Abuse and safeguarding failures do not stop at denominational boundaries. Nor does someone become safe merely by moving from a church to another institution. Written policies mean little if leaders ignore credible concerns.
Their work helped change the conversation
Independent religious-abuse bloggers have preserved records, connected survivors, documented allegations, and challenged institutional narratives long before many larger media organizations took sustained interest. Their value is not measured by claims of neutrality, but by the evidence they assemble, the questions they raise, and their persistence in seeking accountability.
Survivors should not have to persuade a pastor, bishop, or denominational lawyer that their experience deserves to be heard. Nor should they need to launch a blog to get an institution to do the right thing.
A community of troublemakers—and friends
One of the less visible aspects of the anti-abuse blogging community is the camaraderie among its members. Although we work independently, there is genuine friendship, mutual respect, and common purpose. We exchange information, compare experiences, offer encouragement, and occasionally commiserate about the lengths to which religious institutions will go to avoid accountability.
There is a price for challenging powerful religious institutions, and all of us have paid it. Between us, we’ve experienced threats, bullying, intimidation, name-calling, shunning, personal attacks, and attempts to discredit or silence us. Some of the ugliest behavior has come from people who profess Christian love, compassion, and reconciliation. The irony is not lost on us.
We’ve learned that exposing abuse can make the person reporting it a target—sometimes more readily than the person accused of committing it. We’ve watched institutions close ranks, friendships evaporate, and supposedly pastoral leaders become vindictive when questioned.
None of this is pleasant. Some of it is profoundly painful. But our friendships help sustain us. We don’t always agree, nor should we. We share information, encourage one another, and occasionally find humor in situations that are anything but funny.
And we persist.
Not because we enjoy conflict or imagine ourselves indispensable, but because survivors deserve to be heard, wrongdoing deserves scrutiny, and institutions claiming moral authority deserve to be held accountable.
Those hoping threats, bullying, or shunning will make us disappear have badly miscalculated. We’re still here. We’re still asking questions. And we’re not going anywhere.
Required reading: Sarah Stankorb’s Disobedient Women
Journalist Sarah Stankorb chronicles this broader movement in her excellent 2023 book, Disobedient Women: How a Small Group of Faithful Women Exposed Abuse, Brought Down Powerful Pastors, and Ignited an Evangelical Reckoning. Her work addresses how women used blogs, social media, research, and personal testimony to challenge abusive practices and powerful evangelical institutions. Among those discussed are Dee Parsons and Amy Smith; the wider blogging network includes Julie Anne Smith.
The book is particularly effective on the personal price of speaking out. Many of the women did not seek public prominence. They spoke because those charged with protecting people failed to do so. In a reflection on the book, Parsons considered the vital role of online accountability communities.
We recommend it without reservation. Meanwhile, here at Anglican Watch, we’re still holding out for the sequel: Disobedient Dudes.
We’re available for interviews.
Why we consider them sister publications
Anglican Watch focuses primarily on Episcopal and Anglican institutions, while these blogs have historically concentrated on evangelical and related religious settings. Yet the institutional playbook is familiar: protect the institution, minimize the allegations, discredit complainants, and hope the problem disappears.
The theology may differ. The playbook rarely does.
Our relationship is built on friendship, shared commitments, mutual respect, and independent advocacy. It does not mean identical editorial positions or that we speak for one another. We should all evaluate evidence, question conclusions, and correct errors when warranted. Accountability doesn’t stop at the blogger’s keyboard.
Independent voices are indispensable
Traditional religious journalism has a role, but independent bloggers can preserve records, revisit unresolved concerns, and follow cases long after mainstream attention has moved on. That continuity matters when institutional failures unfold over decades.
We encourage readers to explore The Wartburg Watch, Spiritual Sounding Board, and Watchkeep, and share their work. We are proud to call them sister publications.
The Church has plenty of people willing to defend its reputation. It needs more people willing to defend those it has harmed.
Related coverage
- The Episcopal Church could learn a thing or two from Disobedient Women — Our earlier review of Sarah Stankorb’s book.
- Sister publication The Wartburg Watch goes offline due to hackers — The risks facing independent religious-abuse watchdogs.
- Central Indiana Presbytery threatens fellow blogger Dee Parsons — A case involving pressure on our sister publication.
- Attempted lawsuit against anti-abuse blogger Dee Parsons — Another example of the personal and legal pressure faced by watchdog bloggers.
- Why editorial independence matters to Anglican Watch and other bloggers — Our editorial approach and commitment to independent accountability.
- The Wartburg Watch covers the death of Grant Solomon — An example of collaboration and overlapping coverage.
Sources
- The Wartburg Watch — The Basics. History and mission of the blog.
- The Wartburg Watch — Anniversary retrospective. Early history of the publication.
- Spiritual Sounding Board — About Julie Anne. Smith’s background and advocacy.
- Spiritual Sounding Board — Lawsuit archive. Documentation concerning Beaverton Grace Bible Church litigation.
- Watchkeep — This is my story. Smith’s first-person account of the Langworthy case.
- Sarah Stankorb — Disobedient Women. Publisher’s book description.
- The Wartburg Watch — Disobedient Women reflections. Parsons’s response to Stankorb’s book.
- Anglican Watch — Wartburg Watch outage. Our earlier coverage of the publication.

