Meet Anglican Watch: Independent, irreverent, and not going away

New look. More resources. Same willingness to ask questions church leaders would rather not answer.

If you’re new to Anglican Watch, welcome. If you’ve been with us for years, welcome back. And if you’re a bishop, rector, or church official wondering what we’re going to write about next, welcome to you, too.

We’re Anglican Watch, an independent watchdog and advocacy organization focused on the Episcopal Church and other faith communities. We investigate misconduct, expose institutional failures, advocate for survivors, and ask uncomfortable questions about churches that sometimes seem more interested in protecting their reputations than protecting people.

We’re also not particularly interested in being popular with the institutional church.

Who we are

Anglican Watch is an independent, all-volunteer, tax-exempt 501(c)(3) nonprofit. We aren’t affiliated with any denomination, diocese, parish, or religious institution. We carry no advertising, don’t solicit or accept reader donations, and don’t get paid for our reporting. Nobody is getting rich doing this. Quite the opposite.

We aren’t a traditional newspaper, and we don’t pretend to be one. Our work combines original reporting, investigation, commentary, analysis, and advocacy. We have an editorial perspective, and we’re transparent about it.

We believe abuse is wrong. Cover-ups are wrong. Bullying, retaliation, financial misconduct, and misuse of religious authority are wrong. Religious organizations should be held to at least the same standards of accountability they routinely demand of everyone else.

That’s not exactly a radical position. Although, judging from some reactions we’ve received, you’d think we’d proposed abolishing the episcopate.

Why we exist

Religious institutions can do tremendous good. They can also cause tremendous harm, especially when authority goes unchecked and institutional reputation becomes more important than human dignity.

We’ve heard from survivors who were ignored, bullied, threatened, shunned, or told to forgive and move on. We’ve encountered church officials who confuse transparency with disloyalty, accountability with persecution, and criticism with an attack on the church itself. We reject that thinking.

We believe the church should be a place where people are safe, where clergy and lay leaders are accountable, and where allegations of misconduct are taken seriously rather than quietly managed out of sight. When churches harm people, meaningful repentance requires more than polished statements, carefully worded apologies, or another committee. It requires truth, accountability, restitution where appropriate, and actual change.

What we do

Our work extends well beyond individual clergy misconduct cases. We examine:

  • Abuse and safeguarding: Sexual abuse, spiritual abuse, bullying, grooming, retaliation, and failures to protect vulnerable people.
  • Church governance: Failures of fiduciary responsibility, conflicts of interest, secrecy, and misuse of authority.
  • Clergy discipline: Particularly the Episcopal Church’s Title IV disciplinary system, where procedural failures and lack of accountability remain persistent concerns.
  • Church finances: Budgets, audits, compensation, endowments, property transactions, and the occasional remarkable ability to spend money while declining to explain where it went.
  • Institutional accountability: Whether churches follow their own rules, honor their stated values, and repair harm.

We increasingly cover misconduct and accountability across denominational lines. Abuse doesn’t respect church boundaries, and neither should scrutiny.

We distinguish documented facts, allegations, official findings, and editorial conclusions. We welcome reliable evidence that challenges our reporting, and we correct substantive errors. But fairness doesn’t require pretending that every explanation is equally credible, or that every institutional denial deserves the benefit of the doubt.

More than reporting

One of the biggest developments in our relaunch is an expanding collection of resource guides for churches, vestries, survivors, families, and anyone trying to make religious institutions safer and better managed. Our guides address safeguarding, inclusion, accessibility, church governance, financial management, emergency planning, maintenance, conflict resolution, and more.

We also maintain research compilations covering misconduct allegations, disciplinary outcomes, civil litigation, and related issues. Our goal isn’t simply to document what goes wrong. It’s to help people prevent problems in the first place—and, when things do go wrong, to help them ask informed questions and pursue accountability.

We’re not alone

We’re part of an informal community of independent advocates and bloggers who have spent years exposing abuse in religious institutions. Our sister publications include The Wartburg Watch, Spiritual Sounding Board, and Watchkeep. We’ve written about their work and the camaraderie among anti-abuse bloggers.

We don’t necessarily agree on everything. We don’t share a common theology, editorial board, or organizational structure. But we share a commitment to exposing abuse and supporting those harmed by religious institutions. Many of us have experienced threats, intimidation, bullying, name-calling, and attempts to discredit or silence our work. Yet we’re still here. Turns out telling people to shut up doesn’t always work.

We also have a special place in our hearts for VirtueOnline and its publisher, David Virtue. On the surface, David and Anglican Watch might seem like unlikely allies. Our theological perspectives, ecclesiastical outlooks, and views on many issues differ considerably. But beneath those differences is something more important: a shared concern for integrity, accountability, and the future of the church.

We don’t have to agree on theology to recognize that dishonesty, hypocrisy, and institutional misconduct are destructive. Nor do we have to agree on every issue to respect someone willing to challenge ecclesiastical authority and ask uncomfortable questions. The church could use more of that.

Indeed, we believe one of the great failings of the Episcopal Church is the implicit assumption, prevalent in some circles, that theological conservatives are somehow less welcome than everyone else. We reject that thinking. A church that professes inclusion cannot credibly make room for everyone except those whose theology it finds inconvenient. Nor should disagreement over doctrine, liturgy, sexuality, or church governance automatically make someone suspect, unwelcome, or unworthy of respect.

We may disagree profoundly with conservatives on particular issues. But disagreement is not misconduct, theological diversity is not a threat, and inclusion that extends only to people who agree with us isn’t inclusion at all. Welcoming people with conservative beliefs doesn’t mean tolerating discrimination, abuse, or mistreatment by anyone.

Our criticism of the Episcopal Church is not that it’s too liberal or too conservative. It’s that, too often, it fails to live up to its own professed values. And that failure should concern everyone, regardless of where they fall on the theological spectrum. Integrity is not a liberal value or a conservative value. It’s a Christian value.

What we expect from readers

We welcome people of every faith, denomination, and political persuasion, including those who disagree with us. We welcome thoughtful criticism, documentary evidence, corrections, and tips. We also welcome civil discussion about difficult subjects.

What we don’t welcome are threats, harassment, efforts to identify confidential sources, or demands that we suppress accurate reporting because it makes someone uncomfortable. We’re especially interested in hearing from survivors, whistleblowers, former church employees, vestry members, and others with firsthand knowledge of institutional misconduct.

We take source confidentiality seriously. We also recognize that not everyone who contacts us wants a public story. Sometimes people simply need information, perspective, or help understanding their options.

What’s changing

As part of our relaunch, we’ve redesigned much of the site to make investigations, news, commentary, and resources easier to find. We’re expanding research collections, improving navigation, publishing new practical guides, and developing better ways to explore years of reporting.

Our Ask Anglican Watch research assistant and DogHouse accountability index are intended to help readers find relevant coverage without excavating the entire archive. But the more significant changes aren’t cosmetic.

We’re putting greater emphasis on documentation, long-term accountability, useful resources, and connecting patterns of institutional misconduct across cases and organizations. We’re also interested in what happens after the headlines fade. Was anyone held accountable? Was harm repaired? Did the institution change? Or did everyone quietly return to business as usual?

One final thing

We don’t hate the church. We hate what abuse, hypocrisy, secrecy, and institutional cowardice do to people and communities of faith. We know there are dedicated clergy, lay leaders, and volunteers doing extraordinary work. They deserve institutions worthy of their commitment, not systems that protect the powerful at everyone else’s expense.

And survivors deserve far better than being treated as public-relations problems.

So if you’re looking for an official church publication, we’re probably not your people. If you want carefully sanitized coverage that never offends a bishop, you’ll likely be happier elsewhere. But if you believe religious institutions should practice what they preach, that power requires accountability, and that truth matters more than appearances, you’ve come to the right place.

Welcome to Anglican Watch. This dog bites.

Sources

Leave a Comment