The Church of England has approved amendments designed to strengthen safeguarding accountability, recordkeeping, and oversight of misconduct allegations. Meanwhile, across the Atlantic, the Episcopal Church continues to struggle with something more basic: getting its officials to follow the rules already on the books.
On November 18, the Church of England’s House of Bishops approved amendments to its Managing Safeguarding Concerns and Allegations Code of Practice. The changes aim to improve consistency and transparency in handling allegations, strengthen recordkeeping requirements, improve case handovers, and tighten oversight of Church Safety Plans.
The amendments will be circulated to members of General Synod. Under the applicable approval procedure, they will receive final approval three weeks after publication unless synod members request a debate.
The vote is part of a wider effort to reform safeguarding in the Church of England, including developing independent oversight and a national system for handling complaints about safeguarding decisions.
For those familiar with the Episcopal Church’s Title IV disciplinary system, the contrast is striking.
More independence, less institutional control
Earlier this month, the Archbishops’ Council announced the national rollout of a new safeguarding complaints process. Participating dioceses and cathedrals can begin adopting a unified system under which unresolved complaints may receive independent consideration.
The framework forms part of a broader restructuring that includes:
- A standardized national process for complaints about how safeguarding matters have been handled.
- An independent complaints body to review unresolved cases.
- Stronger scrutiny of safeguarding procedures and compliance.
- Greater consistency in safeguarding records, case transfers, and risk management.
- A proposed independent safeguarding authority with professional autonomy and a majority-independent governing board.
The new complaints process is being introduced voluntarily, with mandatory adoption planned for 2027, subject to further approval. The independent safeguarding authority is also scheduled to be established in 2027, with the transfer of national safeguarding functions expected to be completed in 2028.
These changes are not a completed success story. Their effectiveness will depend on implementation, institutional cooperation, genuine independence, and whether church officials face meaningful consequences for ignoring the rules.
Nevertheless, the Church of England is at least addressing a fundamental problem: A safeguarding system cannot command public confidence when the institution responsible for misconduct also effectively decides whether its response was adequate.
Meanwhile, in the Episcopal Church
The Episcopal Church already has an elaborate clergy disciplinary system under Title IV. Its canons establish procedures for receiving complaints, assessing allegations, imposing disciplinary measures, and providing pastoral responses.
Yet Anglican Watch has repeatedly documented cases in which church officials have allegedly ignored mandatory provisions, failed to communicate with complainants, delayed proceedings, or treated canonical requirements as optional.
Consider Canon IV.8.1, which requires a bishop to provide an appropriate pastoral response whenever a report is made to an intake officer. This requirement is mandatory and does not depend on a finding that misconduct occurred.
Nevertheless, we have documented cases in which church officials failed to provide the required response or declined to hold other officials accountable for failing to do so.
We have also raised concerns about how successive churchwide officials, including Clay Matthews, Todd Ousley, and Barbara Kempf, handled complaints involving bishops.
Our concerns include intake officers exceeding their canonical authority, unauthorized factual determinations, procedural delays, and the use of supposedly pastoral alternatives to avoid processing complaints under Title IV.
As we have pointed out before, a pastoral response is already part of Title IV. It is not an alternative to following Title IV.
Nor does the ability to disregard mandatory provisions somehow become an exercise of episcopal discretion.
A lesson TEC could learn
The Church of England’s proposals provide several potentially useful lessons for the Episcopal Church.
First, independence matters. Safeguarding complaints should not depend entirely on institutional leaders’ willingness to investigate themselves or their colleagues.
Second, procedural compliance must be enforceable. Rules about documentation, communication, case management, and pastoral responses accomplish little if officials can disregard them without consequences.
Third, independent review should address not only the underlying allegations but also church officials’ failures to handle those allegations properly.
And finally, transparency matters. An institution that cannot explain how it handles misconduct, whether it followed its procedures, or what corrective measures it took should not expect public confidence.
The Episcopal Church has begun its own Title IV reform pilot under Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe. We welcome meaningful reform. But the pilot’s credibility will depend on demonstrable compliance, oversight, and accountability—not merely revised procedures or additional training.
Indeed, the church has already spent years producing canonical amendments, training materials, and assurances that its disciplinary system promotes healing and reconciliation.
The problem is not simply a shortage of rules.
It is a shortage of accountability.
Good rules mean little without enforcement
The Church of England has its own extensive record of safeguarding failures, and no one should mistake the latest reforms for proof that those problems have been resolved. Its proposed independent structures must still demonstrate that they can withstand institutional pressure and put the interests of vulnerable people ahead of protecting the church’s reputation.
But its current reform agenda recognizes something the Episcopal Church has too often failed to acknowledge: A disciplinary system needs independent scrutiny, enforceable procedures, and accountability for those administering it.
In TEC, officials have repeatedly demonstrated that they can interpret mandatory provisions as though compliance were optional.
Changing the canons yet again will not solve that problem.
Making church officials follow them might.
Related coverage
- Church of England disciplines clergy for abuse, neglect and safeguarding failures. TEC might want to take notes.
- What other churches can teach TEC about clergy discipline
- Episcopal Church prepares to launch Title IV pilot, but serious questions remain
- Episcopal Church budgets millions for Title IV reform. So why is accountability still missing?
Sources
- Church of England — House of Bishops November meeting, November 18, 2026: Official announcement confirming approval of amendments addressing safeguarding accountability, records, case handovers, and Church Safety Plans.
- Church of England — Rollout of safeguarding complaints process underway, November 9, 2026: Explains the national complaints process, independent review arrangements, and implementation timetable.
- Church of England — Safeguarding Structures Reform Programme: Describes the proposed independent authority, complaints process, professional oversight, and public accountability mechanisms.
- Episcopal Church — General Convention Resolution 2024-A053: Documents amendments to Title IV pastoral response requirements, including professional pastoral care assessments in sexual misconduct cases.
- Anglican Watch — Episcopal Church prepares to launch Title IV pilot, but serious questions remain: Previous reporting on the pilot and longstanding concerns about canonical compliance.
- Anglican Watch — Episcopal Church budgets millions for Title IV reform. So why is accountability still missing?: Analysis of reform spending, disciplinary procedures, and actual accountability.







