Burk Parsons: A pastor found guilty of abusive leadership returns to the pulpit

A prominent Reformed pastor found guilty of harsh and domineering leadership is back in the pulpit. Meanwhile, his former denomination has repudiated his church’s efforts to excommunicate three former members, including parents who reported suspected child sexual abuse involving a church leader.

The controversy surrounding Burk Parsons, senior pastor of Saint Andrew’s Chapel in Sanford, Florida, and a prominent figure at Ligonier Ministries, raises troubling questions about the accountability of senior clergy.

Parsons faced discipline in 2019 and again in 2025, when a Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) judicial commission found him guilty on three charges and suspended him indefinitely. In September 2026, the denomination’s highest judicial commission upheld two findings but reduced the sanction to admonition. Parsons then left the PCA and resumed preaching at Saint Andrew’s, which had already departed the denomination.

A documented pattern, not an isolated incident

The June 12, 2025 judicial commission report described allegations of repeated mistreatment of elders, church members, employees, and others under Parsons’s influence. The commission heard more than 50 witnesses and considered conduct including intimidation, discouraging disagreement, harsh speech, and domineering decision-making. It sustained three of five amended charges and imposed indefinite suspension.

Most importantly, the proceedings did not address an isolated lapse. Parsons had pleaded guilty to similar misconduct in 2019 and received an admonition. Yet complaints continued. A second disciplinary proceeding culminating in serious findings raises an obvious question: What protection did the first admonition actually provide?

The PCA reduces the sanction

Parsons appealed. In its September 2026 decision, the Presbyterian Church in America’s Standing Judicial Commission reversed the slander conviction after finding that the prosecution had used an overly broad definition. It upheld findings that Parsons had engaged in harsh, ungentle, and domineering leadership.

The court nevertheless reduced indefinite suspension to admonition, concluding that the lower tribunal had given insufficient weight to evidence of repentance and improvement, including participation in a shepherding arrangement. The reduction was not an exoneration: the adjudicated findings of harmful leadership remained. Prosecutor Jerry Klemm criticized the reduced sanction, while MinistryWatch covered the decision.

Apparently, a second admonition is what passes for accountability when the first one fails.

Saint Andrew’s leaves the denomination

In December 2025, Saint Andrew’s voted 669–108 to leave the PCA while Parsons’s appeal was pending. Church leaders criticized the denominational proceedings and asserted that the relationship with Central Florida Presbytery had deteriorated. After the appellate ruling, Parsons requested removal from the PCA ministerial roll. According to WORLD’s September 30 report, he had resumed preaching at Saint Andrew’s.

It is important to be precise: Parsons did not simply flee an active indefinite suspension. The appellate court had reduced that sanction before he left the PCA. Nonetheless, the congregation’s departure and his resignation ended that denomination’s continuing oversight. The Wartburg Watch has examined the departure and its implications.

The excommunication controversy

In March 2026, Saint Andrew’s purported to excommunicate Stephen Nichols, Heidi Nichols, and former ruling elder David Zima, even though all three had left Saint Andrew’s and entered other PCA congregations. Its governing body cited contumacy, a term describing persistent refusal to submit to church authority.

Central Florida Presbytery’s March 31 statement declared that those actions lacked ecclesiastical effect within the PCA and were improper and detrimental to the people under its care. The dispute was thus more than commentary: a church court formally repudiated the actions of a congregation that had already left the denomination.

The Wartburg Watch documented the controversy. The public record does not, by itself, establish that Parsons personally directed each excommunication or prove the governing body’s motive.

The Nichols family’s safeguarding allegations

According to Stephen and Heidi Nichols, their daughter’s counselor reported suspected child sexual abuse involving Stephen Adams, then a Saint Andrew’s associate pastor. They say they raised safeguarding concerns with church leadership, later disputed its response, and eventually left. They characterize the subsequent disciplinary proceedings as retaliation for speaking up.

Saint Andrew’s disputes material parts of that account. As reported by MinistryWatch, church leaders say they contacted law enforcement, temporarily placed Adams on leave, obtained outside advice, and found insufficient grounds for additional ecclesiastical action. Adams denies the allegations. No publicly verified criminal finding establishes that Adams abused the Nicholses’ daughter; nor has a court adjudicated the Nicholses’ retaliation claims.

Those distinctions must remain clear. But the reported sequence—raising suspected abuse, leaving a church, and facing attempted excommunication—deserves independent scrutiny. The Wartburg Watch examined the family’s allegations and questioned whether the institutional response sufficiently protected those reporting concerns.

Reporting suspected abuse is not the same as proving it. Nor should an institution’s disagreement with a complainant become a substitute for an independent safeguarding process.

What about Ligonier Ministries?

Parsons’s influence extends beyond Saint Andrew’s. He holds prominent editorial and teaching roles at Ligonier Ministries, the Reformed teaching organization founded by R.C. Sproul. The original ecclesiastical record included concerns about conduct affecting people associated with the church and Ligonier.

In responding to the proceedings, Ligonier emphasized that the charges did not involve criminal, sexual, or financial misconduct. That is a relevant distinction but not a reassuring answer to findings of abusive leadership. Spiritual abuse does not become acceptable because nobody stole money.

Stephen Nichols previously held prominent roles at Ligonier and Reformation Bible College. His family’s dispute with Saint Andrew’s and his professional transition occurred in the same broad period; that chronology alone does not establish employment retaliation. The Wartburg Watch explored the institutional overlap.

Repentance is not a substitute for accountability

The appellate court cited Parsons’s counseling, supervision, and professed improvements. Such steps may be meaningful. They do not establish that those harmed received apologies, redress, independent pastoral assistance, or safeguards against further retaliation.

There are unanswered questions: Have affected congregants and workers been offered meaningful reconciliation? What independent oversight remains? Has Saint Andrew’s acknowledged the harm of its attempted excommunications? What protection exists for someone who reports abuse or questions senior leadership?

Our sister publications Spiritual Sounding Board and Watchkeep have long emphasized, in their broader safeguarding work, the importance of listening to complainants and evaluating institutional responses rather than accepting public assurances at face value. We do not represent them as having independently investigated the Parsons case.

The larger problem with church discipline

A pastor admitted misconduct, received an admonition, was later found guilty of additional harmful leadership, obtained a reduced sanction on appeal, and returned to ministry after his congregation left denominational oversight. Meanwhile, his former church attempted to excommunicate people who were already members elsewhere, including parents who say they had reported suspected abuse.

The judicial findings are established; the safeguarding and retaliation allegations remain contested. That distinction does not erase the institutional problem. Church discipline should protect congregants, uphold ministerial standards, and offer remedies when leaders harm people. It should not become a mechanism by which leaders retain authority while those who raise concerns carry the consequences.

For Burk Parsons, the path back to the pulpit is clear. For those harmed, the path to accountability remains considerably less so.

Related coverage

Sources

Leave a Comment