ACNA’s legal battles: Property, power and bishops suing bishops

Records reviewed through November 17, 2026.

The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) has kept the church lawyers occupied. Its legal history includes property battles with The Episcopal Church (TEC), a chaplaincy trying to leave, a bishop suing another bishop and claims arising from sexual abuse.

The parties vary: some cases involve the province itself, while others concern a diocese, congregation or individual cleric. Here is an overview of selected major civil disputes, what courts have decided and where the public record remains incomplete.

The chaplaincy split reaches the appeals court

On October 6, 2025, the Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy (JAFC) sued ACNA in federal court in South Carolina. The case followed a breakdown between provincial leaders and Derek Jones, who led the chaplaincy.

JAFC alleged interference with its corporate identity, trademarks, records and relationships with chaplains and government agencies. ACNA argued that the dispute was inseparable from church discipline and its authority over the ministry.

The chaplaincy initially obtained limited temporary relief: in November 2025, the court restricted ACNA’s use of specified names and a logo after its lawyer agreed to refrain from using them. That interim order did not resolve the underlying dispute.

On September 28, 2026, Judge Bruce H. Hendricks dismissed the case without prejudice, concluding that deciding it would entangle the court in religious governance. ACNA won on jurisdiction; the order did not establish that its disputed conduct was lawful on the merits.

The Fourth Circuit docket records an appeal, No. 26-2438, opened October 9, 2026. We did not locate an appellate decision. A denomination built partly through separation is now litigating the limits of someone else’s departure.

Dobbs takes Jones to court

The same institutional rupture produced another federal case. On February 17, 2026, Bishop Julian Dobbs sued Jones and JAFC for defamation in the Northern District of Alabama, case No. 2:26-cv-00267-MHH.

Dobbs alleges that the defendants damaged his reputation by repeating accusations of financial wrongdoing that he says earlier investigations rejected. His complaint seeks compensatory and punitive damages. Those are contested allegations, not findings that Jones defamed him or that Dobbs committed financial misconduct.

Jones and JAFC sought dismissal. The latest public docket entry we verified, dated August 14, 2026, extended the briefing schedule; we have not verified a subsequent disposition. Dobbs is the plaintiff in this case, and ACNA itself is not.

Abuse-related claims reach the civil courts

The Jeff Taylor case also has a civil side. John Doe v. Winnetka Bible Church et al., filed May 5, 2025, in Cook County, Illinois, names Taylor, ACNA, The Falls Church Anglican, TEC and other church entities.

The accessible docket index records an amended complaint in October 2025 and defense motions to dismiss, with entries extending into February 2026. We have not verified a final disposition. The civil action is separate from Taylor’s federal criminal prosecution, which Anglican Watch has covered; neither the criminal charges nor the civil filing establishes liability by the institutional defendants.

A second case arose from Mark Rivera’s abuse at Christ Our Light Anglican Church in Illinois. In May 2022, a mother sued the church on behalf of her child, identified as Jane Doe, alleging that its negligence enabled the abuse. Religion News Service reported that ACNA and several related entities were named as respondents in discovery, a role distinct from being defendants.

A September 2023 report in New York said that suit had been dismissed without prejudice after the plaintiff’s lawyers did not proceed against a parish with no assets or insurance. The family said it intended to refile. We have not verified a later filing, so the 2022 complaint should not be presented as a confirmed pending case.

There also has been civil litigation involving Jesús Antonio Castañeda Serna and the Anglican Diocese of San Joaquin. KQED reported in July 2021 that an earlier abuse suit had settled and that ten additional plaintiffs filed another suit that April. We have not verified the later disposition of that second civil action.

These cases raise questions about institutional responsibility alongside allegations against individual ministers. The relevant questions include what leaders knew, what they did and whether their actions or omissions contributed to harm.

The property wars produced mixed results

Much of the earlier litigation involved dioceses and congregations that left TEC or the Anglican Church of Canada and became associated with ACNA. Several disputes began before ACNA’s formation in 2009, and their outcomes depended on the particular property, governing documents, trusts, agreements and applicable law.

Dispute Major outcome
Fort Worth, Texas In 2020, the state’s highest court ruled for the withdrawing diocese, applying neutral legal principles to its identity and disputed property.
Quincy, Illinois A 2014 appellate decision upheld the withdrawing diocese’s ownership of the disputed diocesan real estate and funds. It was not a judgment about every parish property.
The Falls Church, Virginia In 2013, the state’s highest court upheld transfer of the disputed church property to the Episcopal side, while reversing the treatment of contributions acquired after disaffiliation.
San Joaquin, California A 2016 appellate judgment affirmed return of disputed diocesan property to the Episcopal side, finding the former bishop’s transfers invalid.
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania A 2011 appellate decision enforced a 2005 agreement requiring diocesan-held property covered by that agreement to remain with the diocese affiliated with TEC.
South Carolina A 2022 settlement resolved diocesan property issues, with substantial property transferred to the Episcopal diocese. Parish outcomes were mixed; a May 2023 order left two disputed parish properties with the Anglican side and one with the Episcopal side. The 2022 settlement expressly excluded then-outstanding parish and betterments claims.
British Columbia, Canada Four departing parishes lost their claim to retain church buildings and related assets. The provincial appeal court upheld that result in 2010, and the Supreme Court of Canada denied leave to appeal in June 2011.

The record supplies victories and losses for both sides. It does not support a blanket claim that a departing congregation automatically keeps its property—or automatically forfeits it.

ACNA is asking for broader church-autonomy protection

The province’s legal strategy also extends to the U.S. Supreme Court. On August 26, 2026, ACNA filed a friend-of-the-court brief in Singh v. Second Judicial District Court of Nevada, a separate religious-governance dispute. ACNA participates as an amicus, rather than as a plaintiff or defendant.

Its brief urges a broad church-autonomy doctrine, a narrow role for deciding religious disputes through neutral legal principles, and immediate appeals when courts reject church-autonomy defenses. It cites the JAFC litigation as an example of why ACNA wants those protections.

As of November 17, the Supreme Court had not agreed to hear the case; the docket set a November 23 deadline for the response to the petition. The brief nevertheless provides a direct statement of ACNA’s position: civil litigation itself, including the inquiry into church affairs, can infringe religious autonomy.

Church trials run on a separate track

ACNA’s Court for the Trial of a Bishop handles internal disciplinary cases. Its proceedings concern canonical responsibility and should be identified separately from civil lawsuits and criminal prosecutions.

Bishop Stewart Ruch was acquitted of all canonical charges on December 16, 2025. The church trial of Archbishop Stephen Wood concluded September 11, 2026, with an opinion due no later than December 21, according to the court’s latest posted timetable. Jones was found guilty of four canonical offenses in August 2026; that ecclesiastical judgment was separate from both federal lawsuits.

A court victory is only one kind of answer

The lesson for readers is to demand the actual order, the actual defendants and the actual disposition. A dismissal based on church autonomy can be legally decisive while leaving the disputed conduct unexamined on its merits.

From Anglican Watch’s perspective, protecting a church’s authority to govern itself increases the importance of credible internal accountability. Leaders still owe their communities honest explanations, fair treatment of complainants and a clear account of how harm will be addressed.

The lawyers can explain who owns the building. The church still has to explain what happened inside it.

Related coverage

Sources

Leave a Comment