Remarks made after complaint over Dame Sarah Mullally’s handling of case is dismissed
Source: The Telegraph
Archbishops are “colluding” to dismiss an abuse investigation, a victim has claimed.
Dame Sarah Mullally, who is the current Bishop of London, will legally become the Church of England’s top bishop in a ceremony at St Paul’s Cathedral on Jan 28.
However, it was revealed in December that she has been the subject of a complaint over her handling of an abuse allegation in which a victim, known as Survivor N, was allegedly groped and had sexual comments made to him by a priest.
The complaint was being looked into by the Archbishop of York, the Most Rev Stephen Cottrell. On Thursday, he decided to dismiss the complaint against her.

However, The Telegraph understands that the Archbishop of York made the decision while he is also the subject of a complaint made by Survivor N, known as a clergy discipline measure (CDM), regarding his “conflict of interest” in the matter.
As a result, N told The Telegraph: “Bishop Sarah and Archbishop Stephen have colluded to dismiss any investigation surrounding the abuse that I reported.
“It is only seeing the light of day now and has been fast-tracked because she’s about to be enthroned in the top job.”
N said that he will be appealing the Archbishop of York’s decision to dismiss his CDM against Dame Sarah to the Church’s President of Tribunals.
Mental health issues
The dispute began after N claimed that he was abused by a priest in Dame Sarah’s diocese of London and that the Church of England’s response to his allegations caused him to have serious mental health issues and had driven him to multiple suicide attempts.
In December, it was revealed that Dame Sarah had been accused of improperly handling a complaint against the priest.
Lambeth Palace officials said the complaint was made in 2020, but was not followed up on owing to “administrative errors and an incorrect assumption about the individual’s wishes”.
It was also claimed that Dame Sarah had contacted the priest at the centre of the allegations, in breach of the Church’s own safeguarding procedures.
However, Church authorities added that Dame Sarah was not informed of the complaint at the time.
As a result, in December, Dame Sarah released a statement saying: “N has been let down by the processes of the Church of England. While his abuse allegations against a member of clergy were fully dealt with by the Diocese of London, it is clear that a different complaint he subsequently made against me personally in 2020 was not properly dealt with.”
The Telegraph has seen documents written this week by the Rt Hon Sir Stephen Males, president of CDM Tribunals, giving the green light for the CDM process against the priest to be considered.
Abuse complaints ‘buried’
As a result, N believes that Dame Sarah “lied” in claiming that his allegations against the priest were “fully dealt with”.
He said: “For five years, Sarah Mullally and Lambeth Palace buried my clergy abuse complaints, and colluded with the abuser vicar in harassing me as a complainant – which drove me to multiple suicide attempts.
“The incoming Archbishop of Canterbury has now been caught telling lies that she had ‘fully dealt with’ my abuse complaint, and the Archbishop of York has now dismissed my complaint while concealing the fact that he himself is subject of a legal complaint in the very same matter.”
He added: “I know the British public of conscience will understand that while the Crown may have appointed Sarah Mullally and Stephen Cottrell, Jesus Christ gave them their P45 years ago.”
A diocese of London spokesman said N’s allegations against a priest were originally received and investigated in 2014 and 2015, and no safeguarding concerns were found.
The spokesman added that a restraining order had later been sought by the Metropolitan Police in relation to N’s contact with the priest concerned and was issued in 2017 and remains in place.
‘Considered and determined’
On Thursday, the Church confirmed no further action against Dame Sarah but said the 2020 complaint against the priest had been revisited and was now being “considered and determined” by the Rt Rev Jonathan Baker, Bishop of Fulham.
A spokesman from the office of the Archbishop of York said: “On 7 January the Archbishop of York issued his determination not to take any further action in relation to a CDM complaint originally filed against Bishop Sarah Mullally in 2020.
“The complainant can under Section 13(3) of the measure request this decision is independently reviewed by the President of Tribunals.”
They added that there was no conflict of interest regarding his involvement in dismissing the CDM against Dame Sarah and that the statutory process was enshrined in legislation.
Under the Church’s internal disciplinary process, outcomes can range from a conditional discharge where no penalty is imposed, to removal from office, resignation by consent and a lifetime ban from ministry.
In accordance with Church legislation, there is a specific legal requirement for a report to be compiled within 28 days of receiving a complaint.
‘Incestuous processes’
Andrew Graystone, an advocate for victims of Church-related abuse, described the CDM process as “incestuous”.
He said: “No one will be surprised that the Archbishop of York has dismissed the complaint against his friend and colleague, the incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, given that in three weeks’ time it will be her job to pass judgment on disciplinary complaints against him.
“Survivors of abuse in the Church of England aren’t likely to have any confidence that they will be treated justly, given the incestuous complaints processes of the Church of England.”
Rev Robert Thompson, a London vicar and member of the General Synod, the Church of England’s legislative body, said: “The dismissal of this CDM complaint by the Archbishop of York may close a case on paper, but it does not close the trust deficit.
“It will inevitably deepen concern about whether the Church of England’s disciplinary processes are capable of commanding the confidence of survivors or the wider public.”
Rev Thompson, who was one of three Synod members who started the successful petition calling for the resignation of Justin Welby as archbishop of Canterbury, added: “This decision does not resolve the serious questions that have been raised about safeguarding culture, accountability, and the handling of power at the highest levels of the Church.
“It instead reinforces a long-standing perception that senior leaders are insulated from meaningful scrutiny by processes that are opaque, slow, and internally controlled.”
Mr Welby announced his resignation as archbishop of Canterbury in November 2024 as a result of his handling of abuse allegations.
Dame Sarah will formally be enthroned as Archbishop during a service at Canterbury Cathedral on March 25.







