By Stinkbomb, deputy editor of Anglican Watch and Episcopal priest
The Episcopal Church has a remarkable talent for confusing accountability with bad manners.
Hurt someone, mishandle a complaint, protect the institution, and somehow the real scandal becomes the tone of the person who objects.
Apparently, we’re supposed to play nice.
At Anglican Watch, we’ve heard it all: We’re unfair, biased, confrontational, overly dramatic, and just plain mean.
But we’ve been trying the polite approach since before Henry VIII started lopping off his wives’ heads. We’ve written letters, filed complaints, followed the canons, respected the process, and waited for bishops to do the right thing.
How’s that working out?
When civility matters more than accountability, it isn’t a Christian virtue. It’s a means of keeping victims quiet and bishops comfortable.
The problem with playing nice
I’ve yet to meet a complainant who told me the Episcopal Church’s Title IV disciplinary system worked well.
Not one.
Instead, I’ve heard accounts of secrecy, delays, institutional defensiveness, inadequate pastoral support, and proceedings that compound the original harm. Seeking accountability becomes a second ordeal.
And when complainants object? They’re told to be patient, charitable, and respectful.
Apparently, accountability is optional. Good manners are mandatory.
In some corners of the church, the disciplinary process seems to operate on a simple principle: The complainant gets the trauma, the cleric gets the benefit of the doubt, and the bishop gets a confidential file.
Everybody wins. Except, of course, the complainant.
Then we wonder why people leave.
Civility for whose benefit?
Demands for civility, forgiveness, and reconciliation often have remarkably little to do with the needs of the person who’s been hurt.
Too often, the bishop wants to avoid controversy, the rector wants to avoid uncomfortable questions, and the vestry worries about bad publicity. Meanwhile, congregants may be unwilling to hear that someone they admire has been accused of serious misconduct.
So the injured person gets told to lower their voice.
Be gracious. Be charitable. Don’t be divisive.
In other words, please suffer quietly so the rest of us can pretend everything is fine.
Civility becomes a weapon when it’s used to silence complaints rather than address misconduct.
And forgiveness becomes coercion when it’s demanded by people who have neither acknowledged the harm nor made any effort to repair it.
The church loves talking about reconciliation. But reconciliation without accountability isn’t reconciliation. It’s a demand that the injured make peace with injustice.
Forgiveness doesn’t erase responsibility. Repentance requires more than a carefully worded pastoral letter. And reconciliation isn’t something a bishop gets to announce on behalf of someone else.
Funny how the people preaching forgiveness so often aren’t the ones who have anything to forgive.
That’s not pastoral care. It’s institutional self-protection dressed up in Christian vocabulary.
Or, to put it another way, the church has become remarkably adept at confusing conflict avoidance with Christian virtue.
Jesus wasn’t particularly concerned about being nice
Jesus didn’t mince words with the scribes and Pharisees. He called religious hypocrites blind guides and whitewashed tombs.
And when he encountered wrongdoing in the Temple, he didn’t convene a listening session, appoint a task force, or refer the matter to a diocesan committee.
He overturned tables and, according to John’s Gospel, made a whip of cords to drive out the merchants and animals.
Imagine the reaction today.
“Jesus has adopted an unnecessarily adversarial tone.”
“We’re concerned about the optics.”
“Has anyone considered the pastoral needs of the money changers?”
Presumably, someone would have filed a Title IV complaint against him for conduct unbecoming.
The Gospels aren’t a license for violence, personal harassment, or abandoning the truth. They’re a reminder that confronting religious hypocrisy isn’t inherently unchristian.
Sometimes righteous anger is the most Christian response of all.
Fairness is an obligation. Deference is not.
Let’s get something straight.
Anglican Watch has an obligation to be accurate, fair, and accountable for what we publish. That means verifying facts, distinguishing allegations from established findings, seeking meaningful responses from those we criticize, and correcting mistakes promptly and prominently.
It also means acknowledging uncertainty, providing relevant context, and refusing to publish accusations we cannot adequately substantiate.
We don’t get a pass on those obligations because we’re angry. Nor does a compelling story become true simply because it fits a pattern we’ve seen before.
And yes, sometimes criticism of our reporting is justified. When it is, we should own it and fix it. That’s what accountability looks like, including for watchdogs.
We should offer those we criticize a meaningful opportunity to respond before publication when practicable, and represent substantive responses accurately, even when they complicate our conclusions.
But none of those obligations requires us to manufacture false equivalence or soften documented misconduct to protect someone’s reputation.
Fairness means following the evidence, even when it complicates our preferred narrative. It does not mean making powerful people comfortable.
If we’ve gotten something wrong, show us the evidence. We’ll address it.
If the complaint is merely that our reporting is embarrassing or insufficiently respectful of ecclesiastical authority, that’s a different matter.
The church is entitled to fair reporting.
It is not entitled to favorable reporting.
And if the truth makes a bishop uncomfortable, perhaps the bishop should consider a different line of work.
Where was your outrage?
To those complaining about our tone, I have a few questions:
- Where was your outrage when complainants were ignored?
- Where was your concern about fairness when survivors reported retaliation?
- Where were your demands for charity when people who trusted their churches discovered that their trust had been misplaced?
- And where was your insistence on civility when those same people were treated as nuisances for speaking up?
Too often, the answer is silence.
Apparently, harsh words about a bishop are more troubling than the suffering that prompted them.
Meanwhile, church leaders wring their hands about declining membership and empty pews. Then, when people explain that institutional dishonesty, abuse, and failed accountability drove them away, those same leaders complain about the criticism.
Perhaps the problem isn’t that people are angry.
Perhaps it’s that they have good reason to be.
We’re not here to make bishops comfortable
The purpose of a watchdog isn’t to provide emotional support to the people it’s watching.
It’s to ask uncomfortable questions, investigate allegations, expose substantiated misconduct, challenge institutional dishonesty, and insist that people with power answer for how they use it.
That doesn’t mean we’re always right. It means we’re willing to say things others would prefer remain unsaid.
And yes, sometimes we use sarcasm. Sometimes we’re blunt. Sometimes we’re angry.
If that offends you more than clergy misconduct, institutional retaliation, or the mistreatment of vulnerable people, perhaps the problem isn’t our tone.
Perhaps it’s your priorities.
Besides, if you want unquestioning admiration, get a golden retriever. Not a watchdog.
Enough already
We’re tired of watching church members get hurt while bishops and clergy are coddled. Tired of secrecy, excuses, and demands that victims remain gracious while the institution protects itself.
If you think Anglican Watch is too confrontational, here’s a suggestion: Spend less time policing our tone and more time addressing the misconduct we’re reporting.
Give us fewer reasons to make noise, and perhaps we will.
Until then, don’t expect us to whisper.
Jesus overturned tables. We write articles. Frankly, you’re getting off easy.
Stinkbomb is deputy editor of Anglican Watch and an Episcopal priest. His views are his own, although we suspect a few people in church leadership would prefer he take up a quieter hobby.
Related stories
- With Christians like these, who needs enemies? The clericalism killing the Episcopal Church — Stinkbomb’s companion commentary on clericalism and the response to abuse allegations.
- Episcopal Church budgets millions for Title IV reform. So why is accountability still missing? — Reporting on Title IV reform spending and the need for measurable accountability.
- Trinity Upperville: Adams complainants say the diocese offered no pastoral response or care — Complainants’ accounts of pastoral support following the Adams allegations.
Sources
- The Episcopal Church — Title IV — The church’s official disciplinary framework governing clergy misconduct.
- John 2:13–17 — John’s account of Jesus driving merchants and animals from the Temple precincts.
- Matthew 23 — Jesus’ denunciation of religious hypocrisy and leaders who impose burdens on others.
- Anglican Watch — Independent reporting and commentary on clergy misconduct, safeguarding, church governance, and institutional accountability.
