No surprises: Corrupt DioNY drops Title IV charges against STC rector and liar-in-chief Carl Turner

Earlier this week, Anglican Watch received written notification that the endlessly corrupt Episcopal Diocese of New York dismissed our Title IV complaint against the rector of Saint Thomas Church Fifth Avenue (STC), Carl Turner. The announcement, while certainly not a surprise, underscores the systemic corruption within the Diocese.

The complaint accused Turner of a variety of canonical violations under Title IV, including:

  • Interfering with a Title IV proceeding by making knowingly false and malicious defamatory statements about the complainant in a case involving allegations of sexual assault and harassment. Specifically, Turner falsely accused the complainant of being a “domestic terrorist,” making threats against the church, bringing a weapon into the church, destroying church property, and more.
  • Engaging in retaliation for filing a Title IV complaint.
  • Lying to the Bishop Diocesan, Matthew Heyd, about the events surrounding the Title IV complaint involving sexual harassment.
  • Lying to STC members about the outcome of the civil lawsuit that arose due to the Diocese’s botched handling of the original Title IV complaint, including falsely claiming that the matter was not settled out of court.

The church attorney moved to dismiss the case, based in large part on the fact that Anglican Watch editor Eric Bonetti was unavailable to testify, which was due to his plans to donate a kidney to his husband, Mike.

However, it is Anglican Watch’s position that:

  1. Turner’s fabrications can be assessed independently as to their veracity. For example, Turner claims that the original Title IV complainant was captured on the STC CCTV system, damaging church property. Thus, it should be a simple matter to review the CCTV footage to ascertain whether this actually happened. Similarly, Turner claims that the victim of sexual assault was arrested for making terroristic threats against the church. Thus, he should be able to share the source of this information. (This, by the way, we have verified to be a fabrication.)
  2. The whole purpose of Title IV is supposed to be working for health and wholeness. In other words, it is supposed to be the church fulfilling its most basic mission. But this cannot happen when, as here, the Diocese brushes off a Title IV complaint and provides no pastoral response.

And to be clear: Members of STC and the community at large deserve a rector who tells the truth.

Indeed, Turner’s lies, combined with the farcical Diocesan response to the original Title IV complaint, led to STC, the Diocese, Heyd, and several individuals being sued; Turner’s fabrications included making false statements to the Bishop Diocesan.

The lawsuit cost the church collectively well over $100,000 in legal fees and resulted in a substantial out-of-court settlement, paid by CPG. STC, the Diocese, and all the defendants suffered tremendous and lasting reputational damage. And now, on top of everything else, Turner is lying to his own church about this situation.

Worst of all, the Diocese is good with this situation.

In what other job can you lie, cover up a sexual assault, get your employer successfully sued, and face zero consequences? And keep your $8 million crib? And even if someone else lied to Turner, including possibly Robbie Giannetta, what kind of unethical dumbass goes around repeating defamatory stuff like this about a parishioner?

Moreover, we still want to see a public retraction from Heyd and an apology. If he’s willing to send an email to every parish in the Diocese disparaging the victim, he can damned well be brave enough to send a retraction. And we will gladly publish that retraction. Such behavior is a minimal expectation for anyone claiming to be a Christian.

Clearly, DioNY under Matthew Heyd is morally bankrupt and in no way reflects even nominally Christian values.

Leave a comment