Saint Thomas Church Fifth Avenue has agreed to a $15,000 settlement of wage claims involving NYPD officers who performed paid security work for the Manhattan parish. The court identifies 24 members in the church’s settlement class.
Respect for the police ought to include getting their pay right. A correctly timed procession is lovely. A correctly timed paycheck is pretty good, too.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Sarah L. Cave granted preliminary approval on July 22, 2026, in Piney et al. v. City of New York et al., Southern District of New York case 1:25-cv-00671. The Saint Thomas settlement class covers officers who worked for the parish through the NYPD’s Paid Detail Program from January 23, 2019, through December 29, 2024.
What the officers alleged
The Paid Detail Program places off-duty officers in uniformed security assignments for private organizations. In the broader lawsuit, officers alleged delayed payment, unpaid wages, and failures to provide required wage notices and accurate wage statements. They asserted claims under federal law, New York Labor Law, and New York City’s Freelance Isn’t Free Act, according to the court’s account of the litigation.
These officers were doing paid work. They were not making a contribution to the parish stewardship campaign.
Where the money would go
The court’s July 22 opinion sets out the Saint Thomas terms:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gross settlement fund | $15,000 |
| Net fund allocated to class payments | $8,500 |
| Maximum contemplated attorneys’ fee request | $5,000 |
| Contemplated litigation costs | $500 |
| Proposed service payment to class representative Randy Chow | $1,000 |
Fees and the service payment remain subject to final review. Individual recoveries would reflect work and payroll data, rather than an equal division among officers. The opinion describes the anticipated recovery as approximately 65 percent of potential wage damages.
Liability remains disputed. Preliminary approval of a negotiated settlement is not a judgment that Saint Thomas committed the alleged violations.
A little respect, please
That distinction matters. So does the underlying question: how does a church make sure the people it hires to help keep everyone safe are paid accurately and promptly?
Parish leaders should explain who checked officers’ hours against payments, who handled discrepancies, and what safeguards now prevent a wage dispute from becoming a federal case. Those are ordinary management questions. Answering them should not require a theological commission.
For a religious institution, the moral standard ought to be more demanding than whether a disputed claim can be settled economically. Wages are someone else’s livelihood. A modest settlement amount does not make that obligation modest.
The July 22 order scheduled a fairness hearing for January 5, 2027, at 10 a.m. Eastern, in Courtroom 18A at 500 Pearl Street in Manhattan. That hearing is intended to address final approval, objections, fees, and the proposed service payment.
Meanwhile, a little respect for the officers, please. Start with the paycheck.
Sources
- July 22, 2026 opinion and order, Document 1105 — Settlement amounts, class size, allocation method, and disputed liability.
- Saint Thomas preliminary approval order, Document 1110 — Covered work period, class representative, and January hearing.
- August 26, 2025 opinion and order, Document 527 — Background on the Paid Detail Program and allegations in the broader lawsuit.






