Lillian Daniel’s comeback tour hits a snag: accountability

The Rev. Lillian Daniel has a comeback memoir and a senior denominational job. More than 200 signatories would like the United Church of Christ (UCC) to find some room in the redemption story for the person she harmed.

Daniel, the denomination’s Michigan conference minister, is promoting Defrocked: Good News from a Bad Pastor for a Better Church. A letter of concern, sent September 15, lists 224 public signatories and 14 private signatories as of November 16.

A surprisingly successful defrocking

Daniel’s published excerpt states: “I had an inappropriate sexual relationship with a church employee.” The relationship occurred during her pastorate at First Congregational Church of Glen Ellyn, Illinois.

According to The Roys Report, the employee’s complaint prompted a 2015 fitness review, suspension, and her departure from the congregation. She retained her ordination. The UCC’s own biographical record shows her returning to a parish job in 2016 and becoming Michigan conference minister in 2022. Her career looks rather healthier than the book title suggests.

Daniel’s author’s note explains that the memoir preserves reactions she had at the time, including some she now finds embarrassing. The excerpt also expresses regret and describes her expectation that the review would establish she was not a predator.

Accountability makes an inconvenient plot twist

The letter’s authors argue that Daniel centers her own suffering while minimizing the employee’s experience and weakening confidence in clergy accountability. That concern is particularly awkward because she now holds a senior leadership role in the very church whose processes her memoir criticizes. They call for:

  • A new fitness review addressing her exercise of power and boundaries in publishing the book.
  • A process of repentance and repair.
  • Removal of the book from circulation.

A November 9 Sojourners review likewise challenges the memoir’s treatment of discipline. A polished account of the pastor’s suffering still leaves a fairly obvious problem: the person harmed has a claim to the church’s attention, too.

As of November 17, Anglican Watch has not located a public announcement of a new fitness review or an outcome of the letter’s requests. The conference’s current staff page still identifies Daniel as conference minister.

The code has no memoir exemption

The UCC’s ministerial code requires appropriate boundaries and prohibits using ministerial power to exploit others. Those obligations do not expire when the book comes out.

As Anglican Watch explains in its guide to adult clergy sexual exploitation, trust and dependency can disappear behind the word “affair.” Forgiveness can coexist with firm professional boundaries and meaningful repair. A senior leadership post should depend on demonstrated judgment and the capacity to protect other people.

UCC leaders should explain how they are addressing the letter’s concerns while protecting the employee’s privacy. Daniel’s career has already enjoyed a resurrection. The church ought to show at least as much enthusiasm for repairing the harm.

Sources

Leave a Comment