Covenant church and school fought to keep shooting records secret. The courts weren’t buying it

Three years, two trips to the Tennessee Court of Appeals, and one rebuffed plea to the state Supreme Court later, the campaign to seal the police file on the Covenant School shooting has collapsed. On August 13, the Tennessee Supreme Court declined to hear the case. That leaves in place a February ruling that most of the file belongs to the public.

Among the parties that lined up against disclosure was Covenant Presbyterian Church of Nashville, the congregation that operates the school. The church was the first private party to ask for a seat at the table, and it did not show up to argue for sunlight.

None of this surprises us. Anglican Watch has covered Covenant since the week of the shooting, including the church’s handling of abuse allegations and its treatment of whistleblower Austin Davis. Secrecy is not a new habit there.

We have also said from the start that the records fight is a free speech fight. In June 2023, we wrote that the issue was never whether parents wanted to know the details. The issue was the public’s First Amendment right to the free flow of information. When the Court of Appeals let the church, school, and parents stay in the case in late 2023, we warned that the First Amendment issues remained.

In July 2024, after Chancellor I’Ashea Myles sealed the file, we called the copyright argument bogus and pointed out that the Public Records Act is not all-or-nothing, because records can be redacted. The Court of Appeals has now said much the same, in politer language. And when the Tennessee Star published one of the journals that September, we republished it in solidarity with the Star and other First Amendment advocates. We noted then that it contained no security details that would put current students at risk.

Our position on the families has not changed either. We grieve with them. But grief does not give anyone the power to decide what the rest of the public may read.

How the fight started

On March 27, 2023, a former student shot and killed three nine-year-old children and three adults at The Covenant School. Police killed the shooter at the scene.

Records requests followed within weeks. Clata Renee Brewer, working with the National Police Association, asked Metro Nashville for the investigative file on April 21, 2023, and sued when Metro refused. Her case, No. 23-0538-III in Davidson County Chancery Court, became the lead case in a consolidated action. Other petitioners included the Tennessee Firearms Association, The Tennessean, Star News Digital Media, and state Sen. Todd Gardenhire.

Then the private parties arrived. Covenant Presbyterian moved to intervene on May 12, 2023. The school and a group of parents followed. According to the Court of Appeals’ first opinion in the case, the church argued that the police investigation was ongoing, that the file fell under Tennessee’s school-security exemption, and that one of the dead was a church employee.

The requesters objected that the Public Records Act says nothing about third parties jumping in to argue for secrecy. Chancellor I’Ashea Myles let all three in anyway. In November 2023, the Court of Appeals upheld her.

What the trial court gave them

In July 2024, Myles handed the intervenors nearly everything they asked for. Her order kept the police file closed on three grounds:

  • The open investigation. Records in a pending criminal case are off limits.
  • School security. The exemption for school safety plans, she found, reached the shooter’s writings because releasing them could inspire copycats.
  • Copyright. The shooter’s parents had handed ownership of the writings to the Covenant families. The families then argued that federal copyright law let them decide who could read them.

That last one deserves a moment. A public records law exists so citizens can see what their government holds. Under the copyright theory, any private party with a claim on a document in a police file could veto its release. Myles accepted it.

What the appeals court took away

On February 4, 2026, a unanimous Court of Appeals panel reversed on most of it. Judge Kristi Davis wrote for the court, joined by Judges John McClarty and Thomas Frierson.

  • The investigation is over. Metro police closed the case, so that exemption is moot. Records withheld only on that basis must be released.
  • School security means school security. The exemption covers the church’s and school’s internal safety measures and plans, which get redacted. The idea that everything the shooter wrote relates to school security, the panel said, “strains credulity.”
  • There is no copycat exemption. The court treated the copycat theory as speculation and said the trial court had created a policy exception the legislature never passed.
  • Copyright does not close the file. The Act requires Metro to let people inspect records, and inspection is not copying. If a requester later reproduces the writings, the rights holders can sue the requester.
  • Victims’ rights provisions do not bar release either.

One detail should sting. The requesters had conceded they were not seeking anything the church or school created about its own security. The one interest the church could legitimately claim was never in dispute.

Metro, the school, and the parents asked the Tennessee Supreme Court to step in. On August 13, it said no. The mandate issued August 17.

Where things stand

The case is back before Myles with instructions to move quickly. The appeals court noted that almost three years had passed since the first request. She must release what was withheld solely because of the investigation, review the rest, and redact instead of withholding whole records.

That has not ended the fighting. The Tennessee Star, itself a petitioner, reported on October 23 that Metro is still refusing to release the writings and is citing portions of the February opinion to justify it. Expect disputes over how much can be blacked out, how inspection will work, and whether anyone may make copies.

Meanwhile, much of the material is already out. Pages leaked, and the FBI posted one of the journals online in May 2025. What remains sealed is the full police investigative file, and with it the public’s ability to check Metro’s work.

The First Amendment problem

The Court of Appeals decided the case under the Public Records Act, not the Constitution. But the free speech stakes were there all along.

Consider June 2024. After the Tennessee Star published material from leaked journal pages, Myles ordered editor Michael Patrick Leahy into court to show why he should not be held in contempt. Leahy’s lawyers answered that the order violated the First Amendment and Tennessee’s reporter shield law. Myles denied that the hearing threatened his rights, and Leahy walked out a free man. The message to the press was still hard to miss.

Then came the copyright ruling. Copyright exists to reward authors for creating. Here it was acquired after the fact, for the purpose of making sure no one could read the work. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) said the judge got copyright wrong. The appeals court agreed in substance: the public may inspect the records, and anyone sued for publishing them can raise fair use.

Anglican Watch is deeply concerned for the families of the victims. Nothing in this post should be read otherwise. But shutting down free speech is not the solution. A rule that lets government seal records because someone might misuse what they learn has no natural stopping point.

As for the copycat theory, we have read the leaked portions of the journals. We see nothing in them that would inspire others. The only real issue they raise is that of a very troubled person struggling with mental health issues. The appeals court, for its part, found that the copycat fear rested on speculation and not on anything in the record.

Why church watchers should care

No one should sneer at parents who fear what the writings could do to their children. That fear is real, and the courts treated it with respect.

Institutions are a different matter. A church and its school walked into a public records case and asked a judge to seal a government file. They got their wish for two years, on theories an appeals court then dismantled almost line by line.

The reflex is hardly unique to Nashville, so a few questions for church leaders everywhere:

  • If a tragedy on your campus produces a police file, will your first call be to a lawyer who can keep it closed?
  • Who decides what the public may know about how police responded: the public, or the property owner?
  • If secrecy is about safety, why fight for the whole file when no one asked for the security plans?

The precedent cuts both ways. The 2023 ruling means churches and other private parties can intervene in Tennessee records suits to argue for secrecy. The 2026 ruling means they will need an actual statutory exemption when they get there. A policy argument and a creative assignment of copyright will not do.

The Public Records Act, the appeals court reminded everyone, is how citizens hold government to account. Churches that preach about light and darkness might consider where a sealed police file falls.

Related Covenant coverage

These earlier Anglican Watch reports examine the separate disputes involving John Perry, Austin Davis, and Covenant Presbyterian Church.

Sources

Leave a Comment