A lawsuit accusing Christ’s Church in Rye, New York of failing to protect children from sexual abuse survived the parish’s dismissal bid in 2022. The church later sued an insurer over defense costs and historical coverage. Public calendars trace the abuse case into 2026, but the records reviewed by Anglican Watch do not establish the outcome of either dispute.
The allegations and the failed dismissal bid
Two women, identified as A.L. and R.C., sued the parish and the Episcopal Diocese of New York over alleged sexual abuse by organist and piano teacher Felix McGuire. The September 7, 2022 court decision describes alleged abuse of A.L. during 1973–76 and R.C. during 1967–77.
The plaintiffs alleged that McGuire had a known reputation for abusing children, that church officials knew, and that he was eventually terminated for widespread abuse. Justice Laurence L. Love denied the parish’s dismissal motion in its entirety, explaining that discovery was necessary to evaluate the disputed question of notice. The ruling allowed the claims to proceed; it did not establish that the allegations were true.
A lawsuit about paying for the lawsuit
According to Westfair’s February 22, 2024 report, the church filed a complaint on February 12 in Westchester Supreme Court accusing Federal Insurance Company of breaching its contract. It sought payment for its legal defense and coverage for a settlement or judgment.
The church alleged that Federal issued general liability policies covering 1967–77. It could not find the policies but said it had located policy numbers and premium-payment evidence. It also accused Federal of refusing to defend it and being evasive about requests for historical records.
Westfair reported that the church denied the abuse allegations and that a spokesperson for Federal’s parent, Chubb, declined comment on legal matters. Those were positions reported in 2024. We have not obtained Federal’s answer or a coverage judgment.
A 2019 New York Department of Financial Services circular urged insurers to help locate or reconstruct old policies for Child Victims Act claims and consider surviving records. It also restated existing claims-handling obligations. That guidance supplies context for the dispute; it does not establish coverage or a violation by Federal.
Court calendars are not verdicts
Later records provide two concrete checkpoints:
- The abuse case: A.L. v. Episcopal Diocese of N.Y., New York County Supreme Court, index 950769/2021, appears in the June 25, 2026 New York Law Journal calendar before Justice Sabrina Kraus.
- The church–insurer case: Christ’s Church Rye v. Federal Insurance Company, Southern District of New York, 24-CV-2012, was scheduled for an April 9, 2025 telephone conference before Magistrate Judge Judith C. McCarthy.
These entries establish scheduled appearances, not what happened at them. As of November 17, 2026, we have not verified a settlement, judgment or discontinuance in either proceeding. The records reviewed also do not document how the Westchester filing relates to the federal case.
Accountability beyond the bill
The records reviewed leave concrete questions:
- What did parish and diocesan leaders know about McGuire, and when?
- What records explain his departure?
- What has discovery established since the 2022 ruling?
The diocese’s own website promotes Break the Silence Sunday and calls for concrete action to support survivors of gender-based violence. That is a sound principle. It should include a credible account of how abuse allegations were handled, with the complainants’ privacy protected. The question of who pays the lawyers must not become the whole story.
Sources
- September 7, 2022 decision, 2022 NY Slip Op 33003(U) — Summarizes the allegations and denies the parish’s dismissal motion.
- Westfair, February 22, 2024 — Reports the insurance complaint and the parties’ positions at that time.
- Insurance Circular Letter No. 11 (2019) — Addresses historical policies and claims handling under the Child Victims Act.
- June 25, 2026 New York Law Journal calendar — Lists the abuse case before Justice Kraus.
- Federal court calendar for the week of April 7, 2025 — Lists the church–insurer case and scheduled April 9 conference.
- Anglican Watch’s earlier McGuire coverage — Our May 2022 report on the allegations.
- Diocese of New York homepage — Promotes Break the Silence Sunday and action supporting survivors.




