Attending church this Easter? If so, you may want to avoid these dioceses, clergy, and parishes

One of the sad indictments of the Episcopal Church is that every Easter and Christmas, thousands of so-called “C&E Christians” turn out for services. And while many parishes pull out all the stops (pun intended) to make a good impression, the experience is not adequate to draw worshipers in on a regular basis.

That said, we believe that, even if someone attends church just once a year, it’s important not to subsidize or tacitly condone dioceses, parishes, or priests who behave badly. Thus, we provide a “no-fly list” below that flags some of the worst offenders. (If nothing else, bad karma sticks!)

To be clear: The list is a judgment call. Some really unethical priests and troubled parishes didn’t make the cut. In other cases, people may argue that the person or place in question is trying to turn over a new leaf. And some may disagree with our assessments entirely.

We’re okay with all of these possibilities.

Three further points:

  1. We don’t attempt to highlight the reasons for our recommendations. The intrepid are welcome to search this site for details.
  2. Several persons and organizations on the list have ties to Anglican Watch editor Eric Bonetti. He therefore did not participate in the development of this post.

Dioceses:

  • Alabama
  • Atlanta
  • Central New York
  • Chicago
  • Dallas
  • El Camino Real
  • Massachusetts
  • New York
  • Rochester

Bishops:

  • El Camino Real Bishop Lucinda Beth Ashby
  • North Carolina Assistant Bishop Jennifer Brooke-Davidson
  • Chicago Bishop Paula Clark
  • Retired Alabama Bishop Glenda Curry
  • Retired Presiding Bishop Michael Curry
  • Central New York Bishop DeDe Duncan Probe
  • Retired Massachusetts Bishop Alan Gates
  • Retired Virginia Bishop Suffragan Susan Goff
  • New York Bishop Matthew Heyd
  • Retired Southern Virginia Bishop “Holly” Hollerith
  • Retired Virginia Bishop Shannon Johnston
  • Retired Maine Bishop Chilton Knudsen
  • Retired Easton Bishop Santosh Marray
  • Retired Virginia Bishop Suffragan Clay Matthews
  • Wyoming Bishop Provisional Todd Ousley
  • Presiding Bishop Sean Rowe
  • Maryland Bishop Carrie Schofield-Broadbent
  • New York Bishop Suffragan Allen Shin
  • Retired Dallas Bishop George Sumner
  • Retired Maryland Bishop Eugene Sutton
  • Atlanta Bishop Rob Wright

Priests:

  • The Rev. Dr. Rian Adams
  • The Rev. William Allport
  • The Rev. Thomas Anderson
  • The Rev. Will Bouvel
  • The Rev. Dr. William J. Danaher
  • The Rev. Ben Day
  • The Rev. Canon Broderick Greer
  • The Rev. David J.A. Halt
  • The Rev. Valerie Hayes
  • The Rev. Whayne Hougland Jr. (former bishop of Michigan)
  • The Rev. Thomas J. Hudson
  • The Rev. Barb Kempf
  • The Rev. Pierce Klemmt
  • The Rev. Richard Losch
  • The Rev. Matthew Machowski
  • The Rev. Robert H. Malm
  • The Rev. Dr. Stephen McWhorter
  • The Rev. Dr. Amy Moehnke
  • The Rev. Caroline Parkinson
  • The Rev. Rebecca Roberts
  • The Rev. Santiago Rodriguez
  • The Rev. Dr. Tom Simmons
  • The Rev. Walter Smedley
  • The Rev. Kelly Steele
  • The Rev. Leslie Steffensen
  • The Rev. Anne Turner
  • The Rev. Carl Turner
  • The Rev. Mark Daniel Schultz
  • The Rev. Oran Warder

Parishes:

  • Advent, Boston
  • All Souls, DC
  • Calvary Episcopal, Bastrop, TX
  • Calvary Episcopal, Front Royal, VA
  • Christ Church, Cranbrook, MI
  • Christ Church, Kennesaw, GA
  • Church of the Holy Comforter in Kenilworth, IL
  • Grace Episcopal, Alexandria, VA
  • Grace Episcopal, The Plains, VA
  • Saint Albans Church, Birmingham, AL
  • St. Alban’s, Davidson, NC
  • St. Chrysostom’s, Chicago, IL
  • St. Gabriel’s, Marion, MA
  • St. James, Port St. Joe, FL
  • St. James’, Texarkana, TX
  • St. John’s, Chula Vista, CA
  • St. John’s, Corsicana, TX
  • St. John’s Cathedral, Denver, CO
  • St. Luke’s, Birmingham, AL
  • St. Mark’s, Philadelphia, PA
  • St. Paul’s, Alexandria, VA
  • St. Paul’s, Dayton, OH
  • St. Paul & the Redeemer, Chicago, IL
  • St. Peter’s, Casenovia, NY
  • St. Peter’s Episcopal, Purcellville, VA
  • St. Peter’s Episcopal, Savannah, GA
  • Saint Peter’s Episcopal Church-on-the-Canal, Buzzards Bay, MA
  • St. Philip’s Episcopal Church, Mattapoisett, MA
  • Saint Thomas Church Fifth Avenue, NY, NY
  • Saint Stephen’s, Coconut Grove, FL

Other:

The Seaman’s Institute, NY

8 Comments

  1. St. Paul’s Episcopal Church
    Winston-Salem, NC
    Rector: Rev. Dixon Kinser
    Multple Problems with Current Rector:
    1. Blocked a Church Member’s Cell Phone.
    2. Sent multiple e-mails to a church member reporting he would have her arrested if she attended church.
    3. One year ago while a church member was ill the Rector failed to check on parishners and would not allow the other clergy to contact him or his family.
    4. Any person on payroll is forbidden to communicate with the above-mentioned family.
    5. The Rector has made incorrect accusations towards this church member: sexual, racist, and the Rector claims he wants this member to be alone and have no one.

  2. Great list please include the Episcopal Diocese of Michigan and Bishop Bonnie Perry. Evil comes in mysterious ways.

  3. Trinity Church Boston is an unsafe parish for transgender people. Multiple issues there among the laity and clergy.

  4. St. John’s Corsicana is under new leadership, and it’s fantastic. Serious, young, principled, orthodox, healing and rebuilding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *